14:01:39 <dtardivel> #startmeeting watcher 14:01:39 <openstack> Meeting started Wed Nov 30 14:01:39 2016 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes. The chair is dtardivel. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 14:01:40 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 14:01:42 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'watcher' 14:01:59 <diga> o/ 14:02:19 <licanwei> hi 14:02:30 <pshedimb> hi 14:02:34 <brunograz> o/ 14:02:37 <dtardivel> agenda for today: https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Watcher_Meeting_Agenda#11.2F30.2F2016 14:03:23 <dtardivel> #topic Announcements 14:03:54 <dtardivel> acabot is currently introducing Watcher at Cloud Expo Europe, Paris 14:04:04 <seanmurphy> cool! 14:04:08 <sballe_> +2 14:04:12 <dtardivel> so, he asked me to lead this meeting today ;) 14:04:12 <hvprash_> nice ! 14:04:25 <dtardivel> #link http://www.cloudexpoeurope.fr/english/about-cloud-expo-europe-paris 14:05:15 <dtardivel> This is meanly a summit for french cloud experts 14:05:39 <sballe_> you mean 'mainly" right ;-) 14:05:42 <dtardivel> He is on stage now for 30mn :) 14:05:50 <sballe_> very cool! 14:05:51 <dtardivel> mainly yep 14:06:29 <dtardivel> another point: If you have a look on github project, we have now a flag 'project/official' on README page 14:06:47 <sballe_> very cool! 14:06:48 <dtardivel> #link: https://github.com/openstack/python-watcherclient#team-and-repository-tags 14:07:16 <jwcroppe> nice, that's great to see 14:07:34 <dtardivel> sballe_: can you merge this patch for watcher-specs project please #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/402979/ 14:07:37 <sballe_> hey jwcroppe! your are back! great to see you again 14:07:42 <jwcroppe> tangential question - is reviwew.openstack.org slow for anyone today? 14:08:11 <dtardivel> jwcroppe: it is ok from France 14:08:46 <sballe_> dtardivel: done 14:08:47 <jwcroppe> sballe_: hey there - yes, thanks - finally all moved and things settled down a bit. I've been trying to get the new house all organized in my 'spare time' :) 14:09:48 <dtardivel> Other announcements from you side ? 14:10:19 <sballe_> no not from me 14:10:46 <jwcroppe> will review https://review.openstack.org/#/c/402979/ after the meeting 14:11:23 <dtardivel> jwcroppe: sballe has just set W+1 :) 14:11:35 <dtardivel> #topic Review Action Items 14:11:42 <dtardivel> Watcher specs 14:11:45 <sballe_> I figured it looked straight forward 14:12:00 <jwcroppe> yep, looked good 14:12:01 <dtardivel> Define grammar for workload characterization need a new PS 14:12:09 <dtardivel> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/377100/ 14:12:12 <hvprash_> yes dtardivel, i will add a new PS 14:12:15 <hvprash_> seanmurphy, thanks for the review and comments. I will take a look on your comments and a new PS. 14:12:32 <seanmurphy> hvprash_: np - hope it was useful 14:12:38 <sballe_> hvprash_: we can work on it together I have thougth about some of the comments 14:12:48 <sballe_> seanmurphy: it was 14:13:05 <hvprash_> frankly, i haven't had a chance to look into your comments. Its been a big week for us due to thanks giving retail etc.. 14:13:21 <sballe_> 100% understand... 14:13:22 <hvprash_> i am going to spend sometime this week 14:13:28 <sballe_> I am glad you guys are doing well 14:13:37 <hvprash_> thanks sballe_ :) 14:14:03 <dtardivel> #action hvprash_, seanmurphy complete https://review.openstack.org/#/c/377100/ 14:14:14 <dtardivel> Define when an action plan is stale/invalid needs reviews 14:14:20 <dtardivel> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/386293/ 14:15:14 <dtardivel> sballe_: or jwcroppe : as core reviewer, could you have a look on this one ? 14:15:24 <sballe_> yes I will do it 14:15:32 <hvprash_> will do 14:15:35 <jwcroppe> yep 14:15:43 <dtardivel> thx 14:16:00 <dtardivel> #action sballe_, jwcroppe, hvprash_ review https://review.openstack.org/#/c/386293/ 14:16:15 <dtardivel> Audit tag in VM Metadata needs reviews as well 14:16:22 <dtardivel> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/391374/ 14:16:32 <sballe_> yes I thought I had reviwed it but I guess not 14:16:44 <sballe_> it is my plan to look at it 14:16:49 <hvprash_> yes, thanks to vincent for thoise comments. 14:16:58 <hvprash_> I need to review that 14:17:29 <dtardivel> #action sballe_ dtardivel will review https://review.openstack.org/#/c/391374/ 14:17:46 <dtardivel> Add improvements to the planner and workflow mechanisms needs reviews as well :) 14:17:56 <dtardivel> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/385871/ 14:18:48 <dtardivel> alexchain is not online. 14:19:37 <dtardivel> I think we have now a complete description of what we should implement. Core reviews is now required :) 14:20:11 <dtardivel> #action acabot will review https://review.openstack.org/#/c/385871/ 14:20:19 <sballe_> ok. I would like some +1s here from non core members as well 14:20:38 <dtardivel> sballe_: ok 14:20:57 <dtardivel> #action dtardivel will review last update on https://review.openstack.org/#/c/385871/ 14:20:58 <sballe_> this is an important specs so I would like some more eyes on it and then we +2 it 14:21:33 <licanwei> +1 14:21:53 <dtardivel> licanwei: do you want review it ? 14:21:59 <licanwei> yes 14:22:10 <dtardivel> licanwei: thx 14:22:22 <dtardivel> #action licanwei will review https://review.openstack.org/#/c/385871/ 14:22:32 <dtardivel> Support Description For Dynamic Action needs reviews 14:22:41 <dtardivel> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/401111/ 14:23:19 <dtardivel> I reviewed it this morning. We can ask to hanrong a new update first 14:23:34 <sballe_> yes just saw that 14:24:01 <dtardivel> #action hanrong will update https://review.openstack.org/#/c/401111/ 14:24:59 <dtardivel> Other specs in your mind ? 14:25:24 <sballe_> just as an FYI I will start working on: https://review.openstack.org/#/c/398162/ 14:25:35 <sballe_> pshedimb: will be co-author as well 14:26:24 <dtardivel> sballe_: ok. is it something you would like for ocata ? 14:26:39 <sballe_> yes I believe we have it for ocata-3 14:26:48 <dtardivel> sballe_: ok 14:27:15 <dtardivel> Let's review actions for watcher project 14:27:27 <dtardivel> centralise-config-opts needs reviews 14:27:36 <dtardivel> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/q/status:open+project:openstack/watcher+branch:master+topic:bp/centralise-config-opts 14:27:54 <pshedimb> i'm working on your comments dtardivel 14:28:15 <sballe_> pshedimb: did you have questions on the dbmanage one? 14:28:28 <pshedimb> Yeah I did 14:28:33 <dtardivel> pshedimb: yes I reviewed one changeset this morning. 14:29:03 <sballe_> pshedimb: did you get them answered? 14:29:11 <pshedimb> Not yet 14:29:24 <pshedimb> Can I ask it here? 14:29:34 <sballe_> sure if it is quick 14:29:36 <dtardivel> pshedimb: please ask on openstack-watcher, just after the meeting 14:29:45 <sballe_> ok :-) 14:29:54 <dtardivel> pshedimb: you have just 1mn :) 14:30:00 <pshedimb> watcher/cmd/dbmanage.py 14:30:10 <pshedimb> which opt group does this come under? 14:30:43 <dtardivel> pshedimb: ok on openstack-watcher later :) I have not the answer 14:30:44 <pshedimb> Default? 14:30:56 <pshedimb> okay. 14:31:07 <dtardivel> pshedimb: please ring me later 14:31:27 <dtardivel> check the state of action plan needs discussions 14:31:35 <dtardivel> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/391383/ 14:31:58 <sballe_> dtardivel: so pshedimb can chat with you rigth after the meeting? 14:32:05 <dtardivel> licanwei: What is the status ? 14:32:08 <dtardivel> sballe_: yep 14:32:14 <pshedimb> okay dtardivel 14:33:07 <licanwei> dtardivel: I'll add a new PS 14:33:51 <dtardivel> #action licanwei will add a new PS on https://review.openstack.org/#/c/391383/ 14:34:19 <dtardivel> Add auto_trigger support to watcher needs reviews ? 14:34:29 <dtardivel> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/403718/ 14:35:25 <dtardivel> alexchain is not online. This changeset is tagged [WIP]. Let move to the next ... 14:35:37 <dtardivel> Specific exception for stale cluster state was added needs reviews 14:35:45 <dtardivel> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/399202/ 14:36:40 <dtardivel> no update ? 14:37:25 <dtardivel> no update ... :) I will ask to acabot to contact Anton to get news 14:37:39 <hvprash_> dtardivel, i will try to find from anton 14:37:49 <hvprash_> he was working on it 14:38:00 <dtardivel> hvprash_: what is the Anton's nickname ? 14:38:21 <hvprash_> eil397 14:38:38 <dtardivel> hvprash_: yes of course, :) 14:38:49 <hvprash_> sure :) 14:39:09 <dtardivel> eil397: ^^^^ 14:39:13 <dtardivel> trying .... 14:39:59 <dtardivel> Add auto_trigger in audit API needs a status 14:40:08 <dtardivel> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/398044/ 14:40:17 <dtardivel> diga: any update ? 14:41:16 <dtardivel> #action diga please update your changeset to fix failure jobs 14:41:45 <dtardivel> Fix rally gate test has been merged this morning 14:41:56 <dtardivel> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/398180/ 14:43:07 <dtardivel> Since last week, I merged several little patches improving our source code. Thx a lot everybody :) 14:43:36 <dtardivel> let's move to actions on watcherclient project 14:43:43 <dtardivel> Add auto_trigger support needs reviews ? 14:43:50 <dtardivel> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/403716/ 14:44:11 <dtardivel> who want to review it ? 14:44:30 <dtardivel> oups sorry it is tagged [WIP] as well 14:45:07 <dtardivel> #action alexchadin please update status on https://review.openstack.org/#/c/403716/ 14:45:32 <dtardivel> Add functional tests to watcherclient needs reviews 14:45:42 <dtardivel> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/389181/ 14:46:32 <dtardivel> I asked to alexchain a new section in README doc. But more reviewer is welcome on this changeset 14:48:12 <dtardivel> nobody want to know how Tempest works for cli ? :) 14:48:20 <sballe_> lol 14:49:11 <dtardivel> changes to make consistent with other openstack component needs reviews 14:49:19 <dtardivel> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/403434/ 14:49:55 <dtardivel> ok I reviewed it this morning. I waiting for an update from Lucky 14:50:41 <dtardivel> 10 mn left .... quick quick quick 14:50:43 <dtardivel> #topic Blueprint/Bug Review and Discussion 14:51:03 <dtardivel> sballe_: your strategy documentation has been merged 14:51:18 <sballe_> yes thank you 14:51:27 <sballe_> thx for all the reviews, comments, and +1s 14:51:34 <sballe_> I will work on the next two docs now 14:52:00 <sballe_> dtardivel: and off course your +2 14:52:04 <dtardivel> sballe_: what about nishi's strategy doc (airflow) ? 14:52:19 <sballe_> I will do all the intel docs 14:52:30 <dtardivel> sballe_: cool 14:52:55 <dtardivel> Any comments on BP ? 14:52:57 <sballe_> I just wanted this one completed first so I didn;t have 3 in flux with the same comments 14:54:01 <dtardivel> #topic Open discussions 14:54:16 <sballe_> I would like to understand if I have to pay $100 to attend the cross project meet up in Feb. 14:54:29 <sballe_> I tried to register abd evenbrite wanted $100 14:54:44 <sballe_> acabot: was suppose to ask ttx but I haven't heard back from him 14:54:53 <dtardivel> sballe_: I really don't know 14:55:08 <sballe_> ok has anybody signed up for the meetup? 14:55:08 <dtardivel> sballe_: I will discuss with acabot tomorrow if you want 14:55:14 <sballe_> yes please 14:56:04 <dtardivel> #action dtardivel query acabot about $100 tax from eventbrite for cross project meet up 14:56:12 <sballe_> also atuly is trying to figure out who to talk to to get a letter for his visa 14:56:32 <hvprash_> sballe_ do you have the eventbrite link ? 14:56:36 <sballe_> i refered himto acabot 14:56:46 <sballe_> hvprash_: yes one sec 14:57:30 <sballe_> https://www.eventbrite.com/e/project-teams-gathering-tickets-27549298694#tickets 14:57:37 <hvprash_> thanks 14:57:46 <sballe_> http://www.openstack.org/ptg 14:58:22 <dtardivel> sballe_: thx 14:58:45 <dtardivel> Other points (in 2mn) 14:59:27 <sballe_> nope I am done :-) 14:59:50 <dtardivel> no, so have a good day, afternoon, night everyone 15:00:16 <dtardivel> please see you again next week 15:00:17 <dtardivel> #endmeeting