13:00:34 <alexchadin> #startmeeting watcher 13:00:35 <openstack> Meeting started Wed Mar 1 13:00:34 2017 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes. The chair is alexchadin. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 13:00:37 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 13:00:39 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'watcher' 13:00:43 <alexchadin> o/ 13:00:53 <Yumeng__> Hi 13:00:53 <acabot> o/ 13:00:58 <licanwei> hi 13:01:00 <pshedimb> hi 13:01:06 <ostroverkhov> hi 13:01:08 <chrisspencer_> o/ 13:01:15 <hidekazu> hi, good night :) 13:01:17 <alexchadin> #info Today we have the following agenda https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Watcher_Meeting_Agenda#03.2F01.2F2017 13:01:32 <alexchadin> #topic Announcements 13:01:38 <adisky_> hi 13:01:46 <alexchadin> #info PTG is over, all blueprints have been prioritised 13:02:24 <alexchadin> We've made it and our launchpad is in order again :) 13:02:32 <acabot> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/pike-watcher-ptg 13:02:58 <vincentfrancoise> o/ 13:02:58 <alexchadin> #info Prudhvi Rao Shedimbi is in Watcher Core now 13:03:06 <alexchadin> #link http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-dev/2017-February/112313.html 13:03:21 <sballe_> congrats! 13:03:28 <alexchadin> congratulations! 13:03:36 <pshedimb> thank you :) 13:04:00 <alexchadin> #info Hidekazu Nakamura is in Watcher Core now 13:04:10 <alexchadin> #link http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-dev/2017-February/112774.html 13:04:23 <hidekazu> I'm honored. 13:04:25 <sballe_> congrats! 13:04:44 <hidekazu> thanks. 13:04:58 <alexchadin> #info licanwei is in Watcher Core now 13:05:08 <alexchadin> #link http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-dev/2017-February/112379.html 13:05:08 <sballe_> licanwei: congrats! 13:05:20 <acabot> #link http://stackalytics.com/report/contribution/watcher/180 13:05:26 <licanwei> thanks all 13:05:29 <acabot> nick with stars are core ;-) 13:05:47 <Yumeng__> Cool! We have three new cores! Congrats! 13:05:47 <sballe_> +1 13:05:59 <vincentfrancoise> pshedimb: congrats! 13:06:00 <alexchadin> It was month was a lot of changes 13:06:06 <vincentfrancoise> hidekazu: おめでとう 13:06:16 <hidekazu> ありがとう 13:06:28 <vincentfrancoise> licanwei: congrats to you too 13:06:46 <adisky_> congrats!! to all new cores :) 13:06:50 <licanwei> 谢谢 13:06:53 <pshedimb> thanks all! :) 13:07:19 <alexchadin> Unfortunately, jed56 has stepped down from Watcher Core 13:07:25 <sballe_> pshedimb: licanwei hidekazu It is well derserved. continue the great work 13:07:25 <alexchadin> #info jed56 stepped down from Watcher Core 13:07:47 <pshedimb> thanks sballe_ :) 13:08:25 <alexchadin> Seems that that all now :) 13:08:42 <alexchadin> Congratulations to licanwei pshedimb and hidekazu! 13:09:09 <alexchadin> any other nnouncements? 13:09:21 <alexchadin> announcements* 13:10:14 <alexchadin> well, move on 13:10:23 <alexchadin> #topic Review Action Items 13:10:39 <alexchadin> Watcher specs 13:11:01 <alexchadin> audit-tag-vm-metadata needs new PS to provide a way to filter tagged VMs by Watcher itself (according to PTG proposals) 13:11:12 <alexchadin> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/391374/ 13:12:43 <alexchadin> #action hvprash update spec with new PS 13:13:13 <alexchadin> gnocchi-watcher spec needs reviews 13:13:24 <alexchadin> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/437261/ 13:13:31 <alexchadin> who would like to review it? 13:13:43 <licanwei> +1 13:13:57 <hidekazu> +1 13:13:59 <pshedimb> +1 13:14:21 <vincentfrancoise> +1 13:14:35 <alexchadin> #action licanwei hidekazu pshedimb vincentfrancoise review https://review.openstack.org/#/c/437261/ 13:15:00 <alexchadin> It is high priority task so it would be great to have as many reviews on it as possible 13:15:20 <sballe_> alexchadin: I can review too 13:15:38 <alexchadin> #action sballe_ review https://review.openstack.org/#/c/437261/ 13:16:08 <alexchadin> noisy-neighbor-strategy needs new PS and answer on questions 13:16:17 <alexchadin> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/398162/ 13:16:46 <alexchadin> licanwei asked to explain algorithm 13:16:56 <pshedimb> alexchadin, we are still working on algo 13:16:59 <sballe_> yes we have that down now 13:17:13 <acabot> I'd like to review it 13:17:19 <pshedimb> i'll update it soon. 13:17:28 <alexchadin> #action acabot review https://review.openstack.org/#/c/398162/ 13:18:01 <alexchadin> pshedimb, sballe_ great! Waiting for it 13:18:32 <alexchadin> #action alexchadin review https://review.openstack.org/#/c/398162/ 13:18:43 <alexchadin> workload-characterization-grammar take a look into other frameworks like TOSCA and push new PS 13:19:28 <alexchadin> hvprash is still not here, so I just mark it for him 13:19:43 <sballe_> BTW that was a great idea to look into Tosca. I am definetly interested in review this spec 13:19:52 <alexchadin> #action hvprash take a look into other frameworks like TOSCA and push new PS for workload-characterization-grammar 13:20:09 <sballe_> alexchadin: chrisspencer_ told me he was working on this spec now 13:20:29 <sballe_> I am confused? or misremembering? 13:20:36 <alexchadin> sballe_: There are a lot of reviewers already, almost all get notification when it is updated :) 13:21:00 <sballe_> alexchadin: I know. I just like the tosca idea 13:21:06 <chrisspencer_> alexchadin, sballe_ +1 yes we will be looking into TOSCA 13:21:24 <alexchadin> chrisspencer_: when do you plan to update it? 13:22:22 <chrisspencer_> alexchadin: will sync with hvprash to make sure it satisfies his original vision. by end of the week 13:23:01 <alexchadin> #action chrisspencer_ update https://review.openstack.org/#/c/398162/ 13:23:43 <alexchadin> it is very long-live spec, we are very interesting in it 13:24:29 <alexchadin> stale-action-plan needs reviews 13:24:38 <acabot> alexchadin : wrong link on chris action ;-) 13:24:39 <alexchadin> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/432193/ 13:25:17 <alexchadin> #action chrisspencer_ update https://review.openstack.org/#/c/377100/ 13:25:23 <alexchadin> acabot: thanks :) 13:25:42 <acabot> you can use # undo to remove previous actions from the minutes 13:25:43 <alexchadin> stale-action-plan has got some +1 already 13:26:08 <alexchadin> #undo 13:26:09 <openstack> Removing item from minutes: #action chrisspencer_ update https://review.openstack.org/#/c/377100/ 13:26:13 <alexchadin> #undo 13:26:14 <openstack> Removing item from minutes: #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/432193/ 13:26:20 <alexchadin> #undo 13:26:21 <openstack> Removing item from minutes: #action chrisspencer_ update https://review.openstack.org/#/c/398162/ 13:26:32 <alexchadin> #action chrisspencer_ update https://review.openstack.org/#/c/377100/ 13:26:37 <acabot> great job ;-) 13:26:57 <alexchadin> who would like to review stale-action-plan? 13:27:02 <acabot> I do 13:27:09 <alexchadin> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/432193/ 13:27:15 <hidekazu> +1 13:27:47 <alexchadin> #action hidekazu acabot review https://review.openstack.org/#/c/432193/ 13:28:02 <alexchadin> action-versioned-notifications-api needs core reviews 13:28:13 <alexchadin> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/420612/ 13:28:35 <acabot> +1 13:29:11 <alexchadin> This is verisoned-related spec and is very similar to others 13:29:40 <alexchadin> #action acabot alexchadin review https://review.openstack.org/#/c/420612/ 13:30:06 <alexchadin> reduce-power-consumption needs new PS and answer on questions 13:30:13 <alexchadin> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/435436/ 13:30:40 <alexchadin> there are some unanswered questions from vincentfrancoise 13:30:56 <alexchadin> and from chrisspencer_ too 13:31:18 <alexchadin> Yumeng__: when could you update it? 13:31:37 <acabot> we discussed it at the PTG and it should focus on adding power on/off actions to watcher 13:31:42 <sballe_> I will review too once a new patch is up 13:32:29 <licanwei> alexchadin:we will update 13:32:40 <alexchadin> #action licanwei Yumeng__ sync your patch with PTG proposals and update it 13:33:19 <alexchadin> #action sballe_ review https://review.openstack.org/#/c/435436/ once new PS is up 13:33:29 <alexchadin> cancel-action-plan needs to give some answers and provide new PS 13:33:37 <alexchadin> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/432264/ 13:34:25 <adisky_> alexchadin: I need team opinion on revert action 13:34:30 <sballe_> yeah I have some issues with this BP 13:34:32 <acabot> we said at PTG that there will be no roll back after canceling 13:34:39 <alexchadin> acabot: +1 13:34:40 <sballe_> as you can see in my comments 13:34:48 <acabot> so it probably needs an update 13:34:56 <sballe_> acabot: +1 thx you 13:35:11 <adisky_> i have no problem in removing revert from it. 13:35:31 <sballe_> adisky_: if you do I am fine with the bp except for the nits ;) 13:35:58 <adisky_> but we have discussed before that revert is necessary, i think i discussed with vincentfrancoise or acabot or alexchadin 13:36:05 <acabot> I can review as soon as adisky_ update it 13:36:16 <sballe_> same here 13:36:23 <adisky_> ok so should i remove revert?? 13:36:54 <acabot> adisky_ : sorry if we missed your arguments but we agree at PTG to not run the roll back 13:37:00 <sballe_> I do not believe we can revert without leaving the cluster in a funky state. and in most scenarios the cluster state will have changed between the actions 13:37:06 <adisky_> acabot: ok 13:37:11 <acabot> adisky_ : any IRC log availbale , 13:37:13 <acabot> ? 13:37:16 <adisky_> opinions on abort as well?? 13:37:51 <sballe_> abort should fine right since it stop the action plan. 13:38:04 <sballe_> You can tehn reissue a new audit to get thinsg optimized gaian 13:38:05 <alexchadin> adisky_: cluster state is changing very fast. Reverting actions may cause unexpected state of cluster 13:38:17 <pshedimb> adisky_, can you explain abort? 13:38:22 <adisky_> acabot: yes it must be in openstack-watcher channel logs. 13:38:40 <acabot> adisky_ : a day in mind ? :-D 13:38:58 <alexchadin> #action acabot sballe_ review https://review.openstack.org/#/c/432264/ when new PS is proposed 13:39:44 <adisky_> sballe_ acabot I will update the specs by tomarrow 13:39:52 <sballe_> adisky_: thx 13:40:10 <alexchadin> adisky_: thx 13:40:22 <alexchadin> Watcher 13:40:33 <alexchadin> gnocchi-watcher implementation needs reviews 13:40:42 <alexchadin> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/438530/ 13:40:43 <acabot> adisky_: please add IRC log in References if needed 13:41:27 <alexchadin> new PS was provided today, feel free to review it 13:41:49 <alexchadin> action-versioned-notifications-api needs final core reviews 13:41:59 <alexchadin> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/427646/ 13:42:21 <adisky_> acabot: ok 13:42:41 <alexchadin> who would like to review it? 13:42:50 <alexchadin> dtardivel? 13:42:56 <acabot> already +2 by vincentfrancoise 13:43:09 <acabot> ok you can add dtardivel on this 13:43:38 <alexchadin> #action dtardivel review https://review.openstack.org/#/c/427646/ 13:43:53 <alexchadin> suspended-audit-state needs reviews 13:44:31 <alexchadin> hidekazu uploaded new version today, chrisspencer_ already +1 it 13:44:37 <hidekazu> alexchadin: low priority ;) 13:44:50 <alexchadin> who would like to review it too? 13:44:59 <licanwei> +1 13:45:00 <Yumeng__> +1 13:45:04 <vincentfrancoise> +1 13:45:23 <vincentfrancoise> oh no sorry I already did it I forgot 13:45:44 <alexchadin> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/438800/ 13:46:23 <hidekazu> vincentfrancoise: not spec, but code. 13:46:24 <alexchadin> vincentfrancoise: you haven't reviewed it yet ;) 13:46:35 <pshedimb> +1 13:46:51 <vincentfrancoise> alexchadin: ahaha re-clicked on the link that was above 13:47:09 <vincentfrancoise> alexchadin: so I'll review it then 13:47:18 <alexchadin> #action licanwei Yumeng__ vincentfrancoise pshedimb review https://review.openstack.org/#/c/438800/ 13:47:57 <alexchadin> Watcher CLI & Dashboard 13:48:21 <alexchadin> There are some PS: 13:48:22 <alexchadin> Remove support for py34 needs final core reviews 13:48:26 <alexchadin> Remove unused logging import needs final core reviews 13:48:29 <alexchadin> Refactor the watcher dashboard enable file needs final core reviews 13:48:32 <alexchadin> Update the path of watcher dashboard enable file needs final core reviews 13:48:45 <alexchadin> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/430627/ 13:48:50 <alexchadin> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/435882/ 13:48:54 <alexchadin> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/429257/ 13:48:59 <alexchadin> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/429269/ 13:49:00 <pshedimb> I'll do it now itself 13:49:05 <Yumeng__> Thx 13:49:34 <alexchadin> they are not big, so we need to merge them ASAP please 13:49:51 <pshedimb> Looks like I'm not core in dashboard ;) 13:50:04 <pshedimb> Unable to give +2 13:50:04 <alexchadin> I will add all core reviewers to these patches 13:50:13 <alexchadin> pshedimb: We will fix it ;) 13:50:24 <alexchadin> Blueprint/Bug Review and Discussion 13:50:28 <vincentfrancoise> I'll W+1 it then 13:50:28 <alexchadin> cinder model integration needs to get review from cinder devs and to be assigned 13:50:31 <pshedimb> alexchadin, okay :) 13:50:37 <alexchadin> #link https://blueprints.launchpad.net/watcher/+spec/cinder-model-integration 13:51:37 <hidekazu> alexchadin: please assign me. 13:51:41 <acabot> pshedimb chrisspencer_ : you talked about adding OSIC cinder team in the discussion, do you want to iterate on spec ? 13:51:50 <acabot> or before 13:52:06 <pshedimb> acabot, Yeah, Chris already started a mail chain yesterday 13:52:08 <chrisspencer_> acabot: I will fwd it to them today 13:52:18 <alexchadin> #action alexchadin assign hidekazu to https://blueprints.launchpad.net/watcher/+spec/cinder-model-integration 13:52:33 <acabot> ok great, please let us know if we need to start a spec already 13:52:43 <alexchadin> cron-based-continuous-audits provide spec with cron and DB persistence updates 13:52:45 <pshedimb> I saw a mail yesterday regarding this from chrisspencer_ ? 13:52:51 <alexchadin> #link https://blueprints.launchpad.net/watcher/+spec/cron-based-continuous-audits 13:53:09 <alexchadin> #action alexchadin write spec and upload it 13:53:14 <acabot> alexchadin : not in pike ;-) 13:53:35 <alexchadin> acabot: oh, you are right 13:53:40 <alexchadin> #undo 13:53:41 <openstack> Removing item from minutes: #action alexchadin write spec and upload it 13:53:56 <alexchadin> service-versioned-notifications-api needs spec and new PS for implementation 13:54:03 <alexchadin> #link https://blueprints.launchpad.net/watcher/+spec/service-versioned-notifications-api 13:54:17 <ostroverkhov> Sorry, I was sick a few days, today added a new the PS, but without tests. Tests will try to add tomorrow. 13:54:26 <alexchadin> ostroverkhov: when do you plan to prepare spec? 13:54:59 <acabot> ostroverkhov: ok could you add a mention to the BP in your commit msg ? 13:55:00 <ostroverkhov> I think tommorow too 13:55:19 <alexchadin> #action ostroverkhov add spec and tests to https://blueprints.launchpad.net/watcher/+spec/service-versioned-notifications-api 13:55:35 <ostroverkhov> acabot: yes 13:55:36 <alexchadin> #topic Open discussions 13:55:42 <acabot> ostroverkhov: and topic should be bp/service-versioned-notifications-api 13:56:01 <alexchadin> acabot wanted to talk about Nova discussions at PTG 13:56:05 <acabot> in 2 min 13:56:08 <alexchadin> but only 5 minutes left 13:56:19 <acabot> I had a talk with ttx about respecting nova policies 13:56:30 <acabot> he had a talk with nova PTL about it 13:56:41 <alexchadin> So I move left discussions to the next week 13:57:04 <alexchadin> #action move left discussions to the next week 13:57:13 <acabot> we aggreed to send a mail on the ML to explain where we are in Watcher and what we need from Nova to respect nova policies, the technical comitee will respond to it 13:57:28 <alexchadin> acabot: nice! 13:57:35 <sballe_> I need to go. talk to you on the watcher irc channel 13:57:45 <alexchadin> well, thank you all 13:57:46 <acabot> I will start an etherpad with the email content so that we can review it next week 13:58:03 <acabot> #action acabot start etherpad for mail to nova 13:58:08 <alexchadin> it was my first meeting as chair :) 13:58:19 <acabot> alexchadin : good job !! 13:58:20 <pshedimb> good work alexchadin :) 13:58:27 <alexchadin> We have to end the meeting 13:58:30 <alexchadin> thank you! 13:58:36 <acabot> thx 13:58:36 <vincentfrancoise> alexchadin: Good job! 13:58:40 <hidekazu> thanks! 13:58:45 <alexchadin> BTW there are two minutes left ;) 13:58:46 <Yumeng__> Thx bye 13:58:47 <licanwei> good 13:58:51 <licanwei> bye 13:58:52 <pshedimb> bye 13:58:52 <vincentfrancoise> bye 13:58:55 <adisky_> thanks bye 13:59:01 <alexchadin> thanks, bye 13:59:04 <alexchadin> #endmeeting