21:01:40 <obulpathi> #startmeeting Weekly Poppy Meeting 21:01:41 <tonytan4ever> o/ 21:01:41 <openstack> Meeting started Thu Nov 6 21:01:40 2014 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes. The chair is obulpathi. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 21:01:42 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 21:01:44 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'weekly_poppy_meeting' 21:01:54 <obulpathi> #topic RollCall 21:02:01 <malini> o/ 21:02:06 <megan_w_> o/ 21:02:06 <obulpathi> o/ 21:02:07 <catherin_> o/ 21:02:27 <obulpathi> anyone from fastly, maxcdn, akamai, edgecast, or hybernia? 21:02:32 * ametts forgot the time changed with daylight savings, and just happened to still have this window open after checking in an hour ago. 21:02:49 <malini> *wish they wud stop meddling with the clocks* 21:02:57 <catherin_> +1 21:02:59 <miqui> +1 21:03:12 <malini> we never argue in this meeting :D 21:03:13 <obulpathi> hhaha 21:03:15 <obulpathi> hi miqui 21:03:17 <miqui> hahahaha 21:03:24 <miqui> hi obulpathi 21:03:44 <obulpathi> I think most of us are here 21:03:48 <obulpathi> lets get started 21:03:50 <obulpathi> #topic Review Last Weeks Items 21:03:59 <obulpathi> #link http://eavesdrop.openstack.org/meetings/poppy_weekly_meeting/2014/poppy_weekly_meeting.2014-10-23-19.00.html 21:04:19 <malini> woot woot..no action items :) 21:04:25 <obulpathi> :) 21:04:28 <malini> tht looks weird 21:04:49 <obulpathi> btw malini: the link sates to 10-23 21:04:54 <obulpathi> is ther ea latest one? 21:05:05 <malini> hmmm..probably not 21:05:14 <obulpathi> I checked on http://eavesdrop.openstack.org/meetings/poppy_weekly_meeting/2014/ 21:05:21 <obulpathi> ok lets carry on 21:05:29 <obulpathi> no review items :) 21:05:41 <obulpathi> moving on 21:05:41 <malini> #link http://eavesdrop.openstack.org/meetings/weekly_poppy_meeting/2014/weekly_poppy_meeting.2014-10-30-18.59.html 21:05:59 <malini> we do have some stuff from last week 21:06:08 <obulpathi> thanks malini :) 21:06:33 <obulpathi> #topic megan_w_ to start investigation SNI and Keyless SSL 21:06:43 <malini> FYI..https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/Poppy gets updated after eac meeting with logs/minutes 21:06:47 <obulpathi> any updates on this megan_w_? 21:06:54 <megan_w_> no, unfortunatley not 21:07:01 <megan_w_> i know that akmaia doens't support it 21:07:11 <megan_w_> SNI is not supported by all broswers, so adoption is still a little low 21:07:34 <miqui> what is SNI? 21:07:40 <megan_w_> investigation is ongoing 21:07:48 <megan_w_> ssl on a shared ip 21:08:00 <obulpathi> good work megan_w_ 21:08:00 <miqui> k thanks megan_w_ 21:08:03 <obulpathi> since we want to aim for the common features supported by all CDNs and browsers 21:08:31 <obulpathi> so can I keep it in action items? 21:08:40 <obulpathi> the ongoing investigation? 21:09:26 <obulpathi> #action megan_w_ to continue investigation on SNI and Keyless SSL 21:09:28 <megan_w_> yep 21:09:34 <obulpathi> cool thanks :) 21:09:51 <obulpathi> btw .. this is the syntax for action items right? 21:09:57 <obulpathi> malini: ^ 21:10:09 <malini> yes 21:10:42 <obulpathi> cool .. moving on 21:11:03 <obulpathi> next is blueprints 21:11:03 <obulpathi> #topic Blueprint Updates 21:11:12 <obulpathi> #link https://blueprints.launchpad.net/poppy 21:11:34 <miqui> my update 21:11:35 <obulpathi> #topic cloud-dns-driver 21:11:52 <obulpathi> miqui: can we go through them in order 21:11:58 <miqui> sure...sorry 21:12:01 <obulpathi> unless you want to go first 21:12:04 <obulpathi> no thats fine :) 21:12:06 <obulpathi> ok .. 21:12:10 <obulpathi> back to DNS driver 21:12:10 <miqui> no thats fine.. 21:12:15 <miqui> lets follow protocoll... 21:12:34 <obulpathi> so, I tested the limitations for DNS driver 21:12:44 <obulpathi> we can create 500 domains + subdomains in total 21:12:50 <obulpathi> each one is its own zone 21:13:00 <obulpathi> and for each subdomain we can create 500 records 21:13:20 <malini> is this for Rackspace DNS driver? 21:13:26 <obulpathi> because of a bug in my code, I though we could create more records, but 500 seems to be the limit 21:13:28 <obulpathi> sorry 21:13:34 <obulpathi> yes this is for Rackspace DNS 21:13:48 <obulpathi> and I finished the default DNS interface as well 21:13:55 <obulpathi> and incorporated it into poppy 21:14:07 <obulpathi> now working on integrating the Rackspace DNS driver 21:14:26 <obulpathi> so lets keep the status of the bp same 21:14:37 <obulpathi> #topic caching-rules 21:14:57 <obulpathi> I have had time to work on this, as I am working on both patch and DNS driver 21:15:05 <obulpathi> once patch goes through, I will take this up 21:15:22 <malini> do you want to unassign urself till then obulpathi? 21:15:36 <obulpathi> sure, that would be agood idea 21:15:38 <obulpathi> let me do it 21:16:05 <obulpathi> ok done 21:16:20 <obulpathi> #topic add-docstrings 21:16:31 <obulpathi> miqui: stage is yours :) 21:16:50 <miqui> submitted 2nd update of the patch.... 21:16:57 <miqui> would be great if it gets merged.. so 21:17:06 <obulpathi> cool ... 21:17:10 <miqui> that the docstrings start showing.. 21:17:22 <miqui> i should be done with a 3rd update this weekend.. 21:17:22 <malini> another +1 & I will merge it 21:17:29 <obulpathi> awesome .. good job miqui 21:17:33 <malini> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/131035/ 21:17:38 <miqui> thanks malini 21:17:43 <obulpathi> malini: sure will review it 21:17:54 <malini> yw miqui :) 21:17:59 <miqui> so basically my thoughts are this bp is kinda like first pass 21:18:08 <obulpathi> also, from on we should start adding the docstrings for the new code 21:18:15 <malini> obulpathi: +1 21:18:17 <miqui> since the code will continue to change at least folks that add new code 21:18:25 <miqui> can then add the docsstrings accordingly.. 21:18:27 <malini> tht should be one of our review criteria 21:18:37 <miqui> malini: +1 21:18:37 <obulpathi> good point malini 21:19:01 <tonytan4ever> So we need to A) raise the limit B） get multiple account ? 21:19:03 <tonytan4ever> because 500 is too low of a limit for us 21:19:07 <tonytan4ever> I think even for early access 500 is too few. 21:19:07 <malini> We need our review guidelines posted somewhere 21:19:11 <obulpathi> #agreed we should add docstrings to our code and docstrings should be part of review criteria from now on 21:19:20 <miqui> malini: +1 21:19:40 <obulpathi> malini: can I assign this guidelines action? 21:19:51 <malini> obulpathi: sure 21:19:54 <miqui> once am done with the 3rd and final pass at this then i'll move on to another bp 21:20:04 <malini> miqui: tht will be awesome 21:20:29 <obulpathi> #action malini to take care of posting review guidelines 21:20:33 <obulpathi> thanks miqui 21:20:38 <miqui> sure...np 21:20:46 <obulpathi> #action purge-content 21:20:55 <tonytan4ever> This one is under review. 21:21:04 <obulpathi> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/129674/ 21:21:10 <obulpathi> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/129674/ 21:21:51 <malini> will review that 21:21:56 <obulpathi> cool .. lets get this reviewed and get it ready for merging by the time amit is back 21:22:21 <obulpathi> #action dns-driver 21:22:25 <obulpathi> this is me 21:22:44 <obulpathi> so this part is pretty much done 21:22:57 <obulpathi> will submit this along with the cloud-dns-driver 21:23:03 <obulpathi> so this can be marked as good progress 21:23:36 <obulpathi> #action patch-service 21:23:50 <malini> #info: Refer to the bps in ur patch commit messages 21:24:04 <obulpathi> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/128682/ 21:24:10 <obulpathi> oh ok thanks, malini 21:24:18 <obulpathi> #link https://blueprints.launchpad.net/poppy/+spec/patch-service 21:24:26 <obulpathi> this is currently under review 21:24:38 <obulpathi> malini uncovered bugs in this 21:24:45 <obulpathi> so currently working to fix them 21:24:54 <malini> thanks obulpathi! 21:24:57 <obulpathi> will get them fixed in a day or two 21:25:09 <obulpathi> thanks :) 21:25:12 <malini> I will have the api tests also all done by then 21:25:28 <obulpathi> #action set-restrictions 21:25:37 <obulpathi> #link https://blueprints.launchpad.net/poppy/+spec/set-restrictions 21:25:53 <tonytan4ever> This one is under review too. 21:25:54 <obulpathi> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/131252/ 21:26:00 <obulpathi> cool tony 21:26:16 <obulpathi> so lets get this one reviewed and get it ready to merge by the time amit is back 21:26:37 <obulpathi> #action akamai-driver 21:26:45 <obulpathi> #link https://blueprints.launchpad.net/poppy/+spec/akamai-driver 21:26:56 <obulpathi> tonytan4ever, updates on this 21:27:00 <tonytan4ever> This one is in good progress, as I just checked in a patch set. 21:27:16 <obulpathi> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/133103/ 21:27:56 <obulpathi> everyone please take a look into this patch and give your early feedback 21:28:05 <obulpathi> good job tonytan4ever :) 21:28:27 <obulpathi> #action home-doc 21:28:36 <obulpathi> miqui, updates on this? 21:28:43 <tonytan4ever> There are a few items to be worked out, both from our side and akamai side, but I am reasonably confident I can make it work in a few days. 21:28:49 <obulpathi> also I am marking the akamai driver as good progress 21:29:02 <obulpathi> cool .. awesome :) 21:29:19 <miqui> obulpathi: no updates, but will start that early next week 21:29:32 <obulpathi> cool ... 21:29:48 <miqui> you can mark add-docstrings good progress.. 21:29:57 <miqui> will be done soon.. 21:30:01 <obulpathi> once you go through next patch set for docstrings, lets make high priority 21:30:05 <obulpathi> sure sur :) 21:30:32 <obulpathi> sure sir :) 21:30:43 <obulpathi> hi miqui, it seems that I can not change it 21:30:50 <obulpathi> can you please log into launcgpad and change it 21:30:59 <miqui> k, no worries.. k will do that niow.. 21:31:10 <obulpathi> I don't have permissions it seems 21:31:16 <malini> i updated it 21:31:26 <obulpathi> also tonytan4ever, can you please update the status of hte akamai-driver 21:31:28 <miqui> done.. 21:31:41 <obulpathi> malini: status of the akamai-driver to good-progress 21:31:48 <obulpathi> thanks malini :) 21:32:20 <malini> I might be making this up - but if u refer to the bp in the commit message, the status will get updated 21:32:32 <obulpathi> so anybody else started with new bluprints 21:32:43 <obulpathi> malini, interesting, will check it 21:32:45 <malini> #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Gerrit_Workflow#Committing_Changes 21:33:07 <malini> for the open patches, update your commit message if you happen to submit another patchset 21:33:19 <obulpathi> cool 21:33:55 <obulpathi> #info blueprint status can be updated using commit message https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Gerrit_Workflow#Committing_Changes 21:34:06 <obulpathi> thanks for the info malini :) 21:34:18 <obulpathi> ok, so no new blueprints? 21:34:25 <obulpathi> we have our hands full anyways 21:34:32 <obulpathi> so lets move on to bugs 21:34:56 <obulpathi> #topic Bugs Update 21:35:03 <obulpathi> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/poppy 21:35:39 <obulpathi> ok, so any bugs squashed? 21:35:58 <obulpathi> yep, so an important ifo 21:36:04 <malini> no :( 21:36:10 <obulpathi> its ok :) 21:36:17 <malini> they breed! 21:36:21 <obulpathi> hahaha 21:36:30 <miqui> haha 21:36:41 <obulpathi> malini: do you want to talk about the API tests being broken? 21:36:58 <malini> hmmm..yes..not broken really 21:37:25 <obulpathi> ok 21:37:27 <malini> But anyways, most of the API tests depend on the service being configured at the provider 21:37:35 <malini> eg. fastly/ Akamai etc. 21:38:06 <malini> This can cause flaky tests if the provider throws errors at the worst..AT the best case, we still have SLOW tests 21:38:18 <malini> we need some way around this 21:38:44 <malini> probably create a mock provider..something tht can mimic provider responses 21:38:52 <malini> I will add a bp for this 21:38:57 <obulpathi> cool 21:39:07 <malini> If anybody has ideas on this, plz ping me 21:39:09 <tonytan4ever> I thought we already have a mock provider 21:39:31 <tonytan4ever> Yes we do. 21:39:39 <malini> hmmm…is it updated? 21:40:17 <malini> tht is not good enough (atleast what we currently have there) 21:40:49 <malini> lets take this to #openstack-poppy 21:40:58 <obulpathi> ok 21:40:58 <malini> I dont want to hijack the meeting 21:41:00 <tonytan4ever> Depends on what you mean by updated. It has some basic functionality as other providers, but it seems like not covering all the test cases you want. 21:41:11 <obulpathi> lets break this out in to #openstack-poppy 21:41:14 <tonytan4ever> ok 21:41:28 <obulpathi> another thing is that 21:41:32 <malini> tonytan4ever: it returns some hardcoded responses, but not necessarily relates to the requests 21:41:45 <malini> anyways topic for #openstack-poppy 21:42:11 <obulpathi> we also need to make sure that we run api tests for all our code changes 21:42:15 <obulpathi> and then only merge them 21:42:25 <obulpathi> we had 2 bugs that sneaked into our code 21:42:29 <malini> obulpathi: +1 21:42:37 <malini> will add tht to review guidelines 21:42:45 <obulpathi> https://bugs.launchpad.net/poppy/+bug/1389766 21:42:46 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1389766 in poppy "API tests for flavors are failing" [Undecided,New] 21:42:56 <obulpathi> https://bugs.launchpad.net/poppy/+bug/1389790 21:42:57 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1389790 in poppy "API tests failing for create service" [Undecided,New] 21:43:00 <obulpathi> cool 21:43:02 <obulpathi> thanks malini 21:43:19 <obulpathi> #action malini to update guidelines regarding running api tests 21:43:49 <obulpathi> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/132889/ 21:44:22 <obulpathi> please take a look and lets get this patch ready 21:44:24 <malini> Reviews plz..another +1 & this can be merged 21:44:41 <obulpathi> this patch addresses api tests for lfavors 21:45:01 <obulpathi> ok 21:45:03 <obulpathi> moving on 21:45:10 <obulpathi> any other updates on bugs? 21:45:35 <malini> not from me 21:45:38 <obulpathi> ok cool 21:45:41 <obulpathi> #topic New Items 21:45:44 <obulpathi> so new items 21:46:16 <obulpathi> so anybody heard from amit about poppy talk at paris? 21:46:26 <miqui> not me.. 21:46:35 <miqui> was wondering how it went... 21:46:44 <obulpathi> me too 21:46:53 <tonytan4ever> me three. 21:47:06 <obulpathi> probably, we can keep this for amit 21:47:13 <malini> +1 21:47:14 <obulpathi> to update us next week, when he is back 21:47:16 <miqui> yeah... 21:47:30 <obulpathi> so, any new items? 21:47:36 <malini> none from me 21:47:51 <obulpathi> cool, lets move on 21:47:53 <obulpathi> #topic Open Discussion 21:48:09 <miqui> i saw a patch about this: http://www.fig.sh/ 21:48:21 <miqui> this seems cool.... 21:48:27 <miqui> am starting to use docker more and more... 21:48:28 <malini> yes!! amit is in the docker wagon ;) 21:48:35 <obulpathi> #topic running poppy using fig 21:48:39 <miqui> am pushing the wagon... 21:48:45 <malini> tht is great miqui ! 21:48:54 <obulpathi> miqui, fig is super cool 21:49:22 <miqui> oh yes...awesome reading next couple of days... 21:49:27 <obulpathi> and amit is already running poppy, cassandra, and repose using fig 21:49:34 <miqui> nice... 21:49:51 <obulpathi> yep, its really interesting tool 21:50:00 <obulpathi> kudos to amit for bringing it in :) 21:50:48 <obulpathi> any other discussions? 21:50:49 <malini> gtg now folks..ttyl in #openstack-poppy 21:50:56 <obulpathi> ttl malini :) 21:50:58 <obulpathi> thanks and tc 21:51:02 <miqui> ttl folks... 21:51:06 <miqui> tc 21:51:09 <obulpathi> ok 21:51:20 <tonytan4ever> see ya 21:51:21 <obulpathi> good progress people :) 21:51:27 <obulpathi> see you all next week 21:51:33 <obulpathi> same time, same channel 21:51:37 <obulpathi> #endmeeting