Wednesday, 2015-03-18

*** IlyaE has quit IRC		00:01
*** kebray has joined #heat		00:02
*** pm90_ has quit IRC		00:07
*** pm90_ has joined #heat		00:10
*** achanda has quit IRC		00:15
*** achanda has joined #heat		00:16
*** achanda has quit IRC		00:18
*** achanda has joined #heat		00:18
*** blomquisg has joined #heat		00:23
openstackgerrit	Merged openstack/heat: Add integration scenario test for Neutron LBaaS https://review.openstack.org/162184	00:28
*** achanda has quit IRC		00:30
*** pm90_ has quit IRC		00:31
*** hdd has quit IRC		00:36
*** pm90_ has joined #heat		00:40
openstackgerrit	Angus Salkeld proposed openstack/heat: StackResource convert operations to use RPC https://review.openstack.org/116336	00:44
openstackgerrit	Angus Salkeld proposed openstack/heat: Pass the environment into the Template class and not Stack https://review.openstack.org/164067	00:44
*** kebray has quit IRC		00:52
*** Qiming has joined #heat		00:54
*** Qiming_ has joined #heat		00:55
*** spzala has joined #heat		00:58
*** Qiming has quit IRC		00:59
*** Qiming_ is now known as Qiming		00:59
openstackgerrit	Steve Baker proposed openstack/heat-templates: pip_mirror param for test image boot config https://review.openstack.org/165261	01:02
*** bandarji has joined #heat		01:12
*** Qiming_ has joined #heat		01:20
*** pm90_ has quit IRC		01:23
*** Qiming has quit IRC		01:23
openstackgerrit	yuntongjin proposed openstack/heat: Versioned object - WatchRule and WatchData https://review.openstack.org/153487	01:25
*** rdo has quit IRC		01:41
asalkeld	this needs approving: https://review.openstack.org/#/c/164591/	01:42
*** hdd has joined #heat		01:45
*** bandarji has quit IRC		01:49
asalkeld	for your convenience: https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/heat-kilo-3-reviews	01:51
asalkeld	stevebaker: ^	01:52
asalkeld	huangtianhua: thanks	01:57
asalkeld	(for the review)	01:57
huangtianhua	asalkeld: np :)	01:57
*** LiJiansheng has joined #heat		01:58
*** dims has quit IRC		01:59
shaohe_feng	asalkeld: huangtianhua: the last version-object https://review.openstack.org/#/c/153487/	02:00
asalkeld	shaohe_feng: yeah see my review etherpad: https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/heat-kilo-3-reviews	02:00
shaohe_feng	asalkeld: great	02:01
shaohe_feng	hope this can be merged in this release.	02:01
shaohe_feng	and any comments, we will addressed it ASAP.	02:02
asalkeld	shaohe_feng: i don't see why not	02:04
asalkeld	shaohe_feng: i was just waiting for jenkins to +1	02:05
shaohe_feng	I 'm also waiting for it .:)	02:05
*** harlowja_ is now known as harlowja_away		02:06
*** hdd has quit IRC		02:12
*** hdd has joined #heat		02:12
*** Qiming_ is now known as Qiming		02:17
*** coolsvap\|afk is now known as coolsvap		02:19
*** erkules_ has joined #heat		02:20
*** sdake__ has joined #heat		02:21
*** IlyaE has joined #heat		02:22
openstackgerrit	Merged openstack/heat-templates: Remove experimental 'heat-config-docker' hook https://review.openstack.org/165006	02:23
*** erkules has quit IRC		02:23
*** sdake has quit IRC		02:25
sdake__	asalkeld shoot	02:26
asalkeld	sdake__: no worries just about the ptl thing	02:27
asalkeld	sent the emali	02:27
asalkeld	well done!	02:27
sdake__	thanks for that, i thought you maybe a day off :)	02:27
sdake__	sine aus ive in the future	02:27
asalkeld	yeah, it's the 18'th here	02:27
zaneb	sdake__: congrats :)	02:30
*** IlyaE has quit IRC		02:30
sdake__	lucky me ;)	02:30
sdake__	thanks zaneb	02:30
stevebaker	asalkeld: cool, thanks for that	02:30
*** IlyaE has joined #heat		02:31
ramishra	sdake__: congrats!	02:31
sdake__	its not really a big deal but thanks guys :)	02:32
*** hdd has quit IRC		02:32
openstackgerrit	Merged openstack/heat: Remove capacity check from AWS::AG update https://review.openstack.org/163743	02:32
sdake__	now, heat ptl, that would be a big deal - wonder who is going to be the sacrificial lamb :)	02:32
sdake__	anyone interested in officiating the magnum ptl election?	02:33
*** coolsvap is now known as coolsvap\|afk		02:33
sdake__	it only becomes real work if there are two candidates ;)	02:34
stevebaker	I'd go for PTL this cycle except the winter meeting time really clashes with family life	02:35
asalkeld	stevebaker: anyone from rht interested?	02:36
asalkeld	curious who the next victim is going to be	02:37
zaneb	asalkeld: for the record, I definitely wouldn't have time atm :(	02:38
*** kfjohnson has joined #heat		02:38
asalkeld	zaneb: what on earth are you up to now adays?	02:38
asalkeld	managing the things...	02:38
zaneb	meetings	02:39
asalkeld	well i hope they are worth it	02:39
zaneb	they're not	02:39
asalkeld	lol	02:39
zaneb	so that leaves only ryansb and therve from RH	02:40
asalkeld	yikes	02:40
asalkeld	rht pulling back from heat eh?	02:40
zaneb	and shardy of course, but he's even busier than I am	02:40
openstackgerrit	Qiming Teng proposed openstack/heat: Remove usage of 'long' data type https://review.openstack.org/165277	02:40
zaneb	asalkeld: no, not at all	02:40
asalkeld	well feet on the ground..	02:41
asalkeld	maybe therve is keen?	02:41
asalkeld	o, well we will soon see	02:42
zaneb	it's more that we've decided we can't leave the tripleo-heat integration to the tripleo people any more	02:42
zaneb	especially since Clint is no longer focusing on that	02:42
asalkeld	yeah, you find out what using the api is like :-O	02:42
*** coolsvap\|afk is now known as coolsvap		02:45
*** kebray has joined #heat		02:49
asalkeld	wow, that etherpad is working wonders	02:54
zaneb	ok, bedtime	02:55
asalkeld	later zaneb	02:55
zaneb	o/	02:55
*** KarolynChambers has quit IRC		02:56
*** KarolynChambers has joined #heat		02:57
*** IlyaE has quit IRC		02:57
asalkeld	for a laugh: http://slim.top.me/wp-content/uploads/2013/10/Cloud-Guy_PM.jpg	03:05
*** GonZo2000 has quit IRC		03:08
*** coolsvap is now known as coolsvap\|afk		03:09
*** Marga_ has quit IRC		03:09
openstackgerrit	Merged openstack/heat: Pin the target keystone endpoint to the context auth url https://review.openstack.org/164325	03:09
*** blomquisg has quit IRC		03:15
*** coolsvap\|afk is now known as coolsvap		03:16
openstackgerrit	Merged openstack/heat: Versioned-object SyncPoint https://review.openstack.org/164591	03:28
openstackgerrit	Merged openstack/heat: Versioned object Service https://review.openstack.org/164135	03:28
openstackgerrit	Merged openstack/heat: Pass the environment into the Template class and not Stack https://review.openstack.org/164067	03:28
openstackgerrit	Merged openstack/heat: Pass the environment into the Template class and not Stack https://review.openstack.org/164067	03:28
*** IlyaE has joined #heat		03:31
asalkeld	oo, mergy time	03:31
*** rakesh_hs has joined #heat		03:33
*** hdd has joined #heat		03:33
*** sdake__ has quit IRC		03:39
rakesh_hs	zaneb: Hi, thanks for reviewing, I also had some doubts https://review.openstack.org/#/c/159444/6/heat/engine/stack.py #LNO 904 I have posted it as comments	03:39
asalkeld	rakesh_hs: i think he has just gone to bed	03:41
*** sdake has joined #heat		03:41
*** sarob has joined #heat		03:41
rakesh_hs	oh ok sorry, saw his comments now, and replied	03:41
rakesh_hs	I will address the other comments by then	03:41
openstackgerrit	Steve Baker proposed openstack/heat: Func tests use fedora-heat-test-image https://review.openstack.org/163287	03:42
openstackgerrit	Steve Baker proposed openstack/heat: iniset heat_integrationtests.conf https://review.openstack.org/165286	03:42
openstackgerrit	Steve Baker proposed openstack/heat: WIP Enable software config integration test https://review.openstack.org/165287	03:42
openstackgerrit	Merged openstack/heat-specs: Add Trove cluster resource https://review.openstack.org/159128	03:45
*** sarob has quit IRC		03:47
*** IlyaE has quit IRC		03:53
asalkeld	Qiming: been super crazy busy -> http://stackalytics.com/?project_type=all&metric=commits	03:54
asalkeld	Qiming: wow #1	03:55
*** vijayagurug has joined #heat		03:56
*** asdf1234 has joined #heat		03:58
stevebaker	I have no idea what senlin is	03:59
asalkeld	stevebaker: our new autoscaling project	03:59
asalkeld	Qiming: is just doing it	03:59
stevebaker	sweet, someone needs to	04:00
*** Marga_ has joined #heat		04:11
*** Marga__ has joined #heat		04:12
*** Marga_ has quit IRC		04:16
*** IlyaE has joined #heat		04:16
elynn	Hi do you know how to run python34 tests for heatclient?	04:23
elynn	tox -epy34 seems not work for me.	04:24
elynn	No mater what unittests I run , it always return a error	04:26
elynn	error: testr failed (3)	04:26
elynn	and no details for what tests are failed.	04:26
*** kebray has quit IRC		04:30
*** kebray has joined #heat		04:31
*** IlyaE has quit IRC		04:35
*** hdd has quit IRC		04:38
asalkeld	elynn: you need to install python34	04:38
elynn	already installed.	04:40
elynn	.tox/py34/bin/python -m testtools.run heatclient.tests.test_template_utils	04:41
elynn	this could work.	04:41
elynn	ha	04:41
asalkeld	brb, picking kids up from school	04:42
*** boris-42 has joined #heat		04:47
openstackgerrit	Ethan Lynn proposed openstack/python-heatclient: Parse nested files if they are template https://review.openstack.org/164417	04:48
lifeless	elynn: try	04:51
lifeless	elynn: . .tox/py34/bin/activate	04:51
lifeless	elynn: testr run	04:51
lifeless	then you'll see testr's full output	04:51
*** rakesh_hs has quit IRC		04:55
*** IlyaE has joined #heat		05:02
*** achanda has joined #heat		05:06
elynn	thanks lifeless , will have a try.	05:08
*** sdake_ has quit IRC		05:13
*** sdake has quit IRC		05:13
*** xek has quit IRC		05:18
*** nkhare has joined #heat		05:21
openstackgerrit	Angus Salkeld proposed openstack/heat: StackResource convert operations to use RPC https://review.openstack.org/116336	05:22
*** sarob has joined #heat		05:43
*** Yanyanhu has joined #heat		05:49
*** sarob has quit IRC		05:49
*** Yanyan has joined #heat		05:56
*** Yanyanhu has quit IRC		06:00
*** asdf1234 has quit IRC		06:02
*** Tango has quit IRC		06:08
*** Yanyanhu has joined #heat		06:14
*** asdf1234 has joined #heat		06:16
*** Yanyan has quit IRC		06:16
*** Yanyan has joined #heat		06:17
*** Yanyanhu has quit IRC		06:20
*** achanda has quit IRC		06:25
*** Yanyan has quit IRC		06:26
*** Yanyan has joined #heat		06:26
*** achanda has joined #heat		06:27
*** liusheng has quit IRC		06:31
*** liusheng has joined #heat		06:31
*** inc0 has joined #heat		06:31
inc0	good morning	06:31
*** ishant has joined #heat		06:35
*** IlyaE has quit IRC		06:36
*** Yanyanhu has joined #heat		06:36
*** Yanyan has quit IRC		06:37
*** KarolynChambers has quit IRC		06:39
*** rakesh_hs has joined #heat		06:40
openstackgerrit	yuntongjin proposed openstack/heat: Versioned object - WatchRule and WatchData https://review.openstack.org/153487	06:40
*** KanagarajM has joined #heat		06:45
*** sarob has joined #heat		06:45
*** Yanyan has joined #heat		06:45
inc0	asalkeld, hello, https://bugs.launchpad.net/heat/+bug/1433340 I started to think about it	06:46
openstack	Launchpad bug 1433340 in heat "stack actions do not guarantee that the stack will be placed into IN_PROGRESS by the time they return" [High,Triaged]	06:46
inc0	we can't really assume we have correct status at any given point of time - a pain of async...	06:46
*** jtomasek has joined #heat		06:47
*** rakesh_hs has quit IRC		06:49
*** Yanyanhu has quit IRC		06:49
inc0	one solution I can think of is to introduce some sort of action queue, an db table which will be sychronious, when we call stack-update we add record	06:49
inc0	and when it completes we update record	06:49
inc0	and stack is complete only when latest record is complete	06:50
*** sarob has quit IRC		06:50
*** kebray has quit IRC		06:51
asalkeld	inc0: it's not very hard	06:53
asalkeld	we just need to not create the thread until we have set the state	06:53
asalkeld	we do very little until that point	06:53
*** Yanyanhu has joined #heat		06:54
asalkeld	https://github.com/openstack/heat/blob/master/heat/engine/stack.py#L645-L662	06:54
asalkeld	just move that logic to before it's run in the green thread	06:55
inc0	yeah...but what about current stack_update running?	06:56
asalkeld	it's within the lock	06:56
*** Yanyan has quit IRC		06:56
asalkeld	lock, then set state, then run task	06:57
inc0	then release lock, and before that we call stack update, and we can't set new state before last one release lock..	06:57
inc0	or am I missing something?	06:57
asalkeld	huh?	06:58
inc0	hold on, I'll digest what you've just;)	06:59
asalkeld	inc0: we release lock when the action is done	06:59
inc0	yeah, thats my point, so we will block creation of green thread until that	07:00
asalkeld	it's just moving a small bit of logic from stack.py into service.py	07:00
asalkeld	inc0: yes	07:00
inc0	so if person calls stack_update, we won't be able to guarantee that stack will be in update_in_progress when it returns?	07:01
inc0	or will we block return until previous upgrade is complete?	07:01
asalkeld	inc0: if there is an update we will get ActionInProgress (same as now)	07:01
asalkeld	that doesn't change	07:02
inc0	only that won't be action we're calling for right?:)	07:02
asalkeld	inc0: that's an exception - your update will fail	07:03
inc0	ok, I get it now...I'll look deeper into code	07:04
asalkeld	i just want to know that my action has started when the call returns	07:04
asalkeld	or it must fail	07:04
asalkeld	otherwise it's really hard to figure out what's going on	07:04
inc0	that will be kinda cheating tho, because in reality they will not yet start;)	07:04
asalkeld	inc0: well at least i can query it and the state makes sense	07:05
inc0	yeah, true	07:05
*** Trozz has joined #heat		07:05
asalkeld	atm i can query it and actually not be any more informed	07:05
inc0	other alternative would be something like upgrade_init	07:05
*** IlyaE has joined #heat		07:05
inc0	and then in_prog when its actually in progress	07:06
asalkeld	i then in progress is fine	07:06
asalkeld	dont' want yet more states	07:06
inc0	I guess there isn't much value added by init status	07:06
asalkeld	but sure, as long as something changes	07:06
inc0	there are events for more inquisitive users	07:07
inc0	(ah, using complicated english words and hoping I've used them in correct context...)	07:07
asalkeld	inc0: that's not very efficient	07:07
asalkeld	this comes from me wanting more certainty in stack_resource.py	07:08
inc0	I mean, I agree that we can solve that by putting in_progress immediately	07:08
*** Yanyan has joined #heat		07:09
inc0	and if person wants to check whats really going on, he can check events	07:09
*** jtomasek has quit IRC		07:10
inc0	allright, thanks for claryfying that, I'll think some more about this action queue tho...I think there are few good use cases for that	07:11
inc0	like queue of updates to make one stack-create contains few single atomic upgrades...	07:12
*** Yanyanhu has quit IRC		07:13
*** IlyaE has quit IRC		07:13
KanagarajM	asalkeld: are we maintaining the api-ref for heat in heat repo https://github.com/openstack/heat/tree/master/doc/docbkx/api-ref, but openstack-api to be use instead, right?	07:14
*** asdf1234 has quit IRC		07:15
KanagarajM	asalkeld: recently i have introduced changes in openstack api-site repo for new REST api changes, so wanted to know wheter it should be changes in heat repo as well?	07:16
asalkeld	KanagarajM: for the api just make the changes in api-site	07:29
asalkeld	not sure why we have the intree one	07:30
*** jprovazn has joined #heat		07:34
KanagarajM	ok, may be we can remove it as it doesn't hold any value now	07:34
*** achanda has quit IRC		07:35
KanagarajM	and https://github.com/openstack/heat/tree/master/doc/docbkx/README.rst says, evently we move from heat to api-site,	07:38
KanagarajM	for admin guide, i'm trying to collect content and evetually will place them in the openstack-manual repo.	07:39
*** achanda has joined #heat		07:39
*** jtomasek has joined #heat		07:46
*** Yanyan has quit IRC		07:46
openstackgerrit	Merged openstack/heat: Add OS::Trove::Cluster resource https://review.openstack.org/159463	07:46
*** sarob has joined #heat		07:46
*** ishant has quit IRC		07:50
*** ishant has joined #heat		07:51
*** sarob has quit IRC		07:51
*** KarolynChambers has joined #heat		07:53
*** jcoufal has joined #heat		07:55
*** jtomasek has quit IRC		08:01
ishant	asalkeld: Hi	08:03
ishant	asalkeld: I am working on this blueprint https://blueprints.launchpad.net/heat/+spec/lazy-load-outputs . Can you please assign this to me?	08:03
*** shardy has joined #heat		08:04
*** KarolynChambers has quit IRC		08:04
*** KarolynChambers has joined #heat		08:06
*** pas-ha has joined #heat		08:08
*** dulek has joined #heat		08:09
*** achanda has quit IRC		08:10
pas-ha	morning all	08:12
*** Marga__ has quit IRC		08:13
*** KarolynChambers has quit IRC		08:13
*** KarolynChambers has joined #heat		08:15
*** KarolynChambers has quit IRC		08:17
*** KarolynChambers has joined #heat		08:18
*** KarolynChambers has quit IRC		08:20
*** KarolynChambers has joined #heat		08:22
cmyster	mmorning pas-ha	08:22
cmyster	-m	08:22
*** jistr has joined #heat		08:22
asalkeld	ishant: no problem	08:23
shadower	hey everyone	08:24
*** KarolynChambers has quit IRC		08:24
cmyster	hey	08:24
shardy	morning all	08:25
*** lsmola has joined #heat		08:25
*** KarolynChambers has joined #heat		08:26
cmyster	morning	08:26
asalkeld	hi all	08:27
asalkeld	ishant: done	08:27
inc0	https://review.openstack.org/#/c/153487/ guys can I have review plz? it already had 2 * +2 but had to rebase..	08:27
cmyster	ls -rtl	08:27
cmyster	ls -rtl	08:27
cmyster	umm	08:28
cmyster	more coffeee....	08:28
*** Trozz is now known as zzTrozz		08:28
*** zzTrozz is now known as Trozz		08:28
*** ifarkas has joined #heat		08:30
pas-ha	asalkeld, you W+1ed just as was giving my +2 :)	08:31
asalkeld	:-)	08:32
inc0	thanks a lot, that was fast:)	08:32
ishant	asalkeld: thanks	08:35
asalkeld	pas-ha: that's odd	08:35
asalkeld	i didn't change the db schema at all	08:35
shardy	shadower: hey, sorry for the delay on the init_complete patch - I've been having trouble finding an approach to persist that state which doesn't break things :(	08:36
shardy	shadower: about to have my third attempt, will let you know how it goes..	08:36
asalkeld	pas-ha: and i have never seen that unit test failer	08:36
*** Yanyanhu has joined #heat		08:36
pas-ha	asalkeld, most probably an implicit rebase done by gerrit introduced those.. and may be some other artifacts	08:37
asalkeld	i tried a recheck	08:37
asalkeld	(i did rebase not long ago)	08:37
pas-ha	ok, let's see	08:37
pas-ha	may be a DB glitch..	08:37
asalkeld	busy time for infra	08:38
inc0	I remember after juno, when gates took 24h to finish	08:42
inc0	that was bad.	08:42
asalkeld	yeah	08:43
shardy	24h w/multiple rechecks :-O	08:43
asalkeld	and one day till ff	08:44
asalkeld	ok test are fine locally	08:44
openstackgerrit	Angus Salkeld proposed openstack/heat: StackResource convert operations to use RPC https://review.openstack.org/116336	08:44
asalkeld	try again	08:44
*** Yanyan has joined #heat		08:46
shadower	shardy: thanks, no worries	08:48
shadower	I assumed it wasn't trivial	08:48
shadower	shardy: anything I could help with?	08:49
*** Yanyanhu has quit IRC		08:50
*** rakesh_hs_ has joined #heat		08:53
*** BManojlovic has joined #heat		08:57
openstackgerrit	Karolyn Chambers proposed openstack/heat: Implements stack lifecycle scheduler hints https://review.openstack.org/96889	08:57
shardy	shadower: maybe, I'll tidy up what I have and post it shortly	09:01
shardy	there are several inter-related problems	09:02
shardy	1. Several places make state assumptions based on the resource having an ID (not by checking the actual state)	09:02
*** Yanyanhu has joined #heat		09:03
shardy	2. The resource _store() method stores resolved metadata, so this is wrong if you store() before CREATE_IN_PROGRESS, but then the store_or_update doesn't then store metadata at all	09:03
shardy	3. There's something odd in the AutoScalingGroup/InstanceGroup code so even if you store all resources in stack.Stack.store, the nested resources inside the group aren't stored	09:04
shardy	Some fresh eyes may help :)	09:04
*** Yanyan has quit IRC		09:05
*** erkules_ is now known as erkules		09:07
*** erkules has joined #heat		09:07
*** boris-42 has quit IRC		09:12
*** Yanyan has joined #heat		09:20
openstackgerrit	Ethan Lynn proposed openstack/heat: Switch config deferred_auth_method to trusts by default https://review.openstack.org/122177	09:21
*** Yanyanhu has quit IRC		09:23
*** blues-man has joined #heat		09:25
*** Yanyanhu has joined #heat		09:26
*** Yanyan has quit IRC		09:29
*** Yanyan has joined #heat		09:31
*** dmn_ has joined #heat		09:34
dmn_	shardy: support for ansible in HOT is same as puppet?	09:34
shardy	dmn_: There is an ansible software config hook, yes	09:35
shardy	HOT, the DSL, doesn't care about what CM tool you use, the interface is in the in-instance hook script	09:35
*** Yanyanhu has quit IRC		09:36
elynn	https://review.openstack.org/#/c/164417/ https://review.openstack.org/#/c/122177/	09:36
elynn	^_^	09:36
shardy	https://github.com/openstack/heat-templates/tree/master/hot/software-config/elements/heat-config-ansible/install.d	09:36
shardy	dmn_: ^^	09:36
openstackgerrit	Kanagaraj Manickam proposed openstack/heat: Fix SoftwareConfigService to use Resource object https://review.openstack.org/165342	09:37
openstackgerrit	Merged openstack/heat: Versioned object - WatchRule and WatchData https://review.openstack.org/153487	09:38
dmn_	shardy: oh okay	09:38
*** sorantis has joined #heat		09:38
inc0	asalkeld, last versioned objects has been merged:) mind setting up bp as implemented?	09:39
openstackgerrit	Kanagaraj Manickam proposed openstack/heat: Fixes SoftwareConfigService to use Resource object https://review.openstack.org/165342	09:39
asalkeld	inc0: great job	09:41
inc0	ah, its already done, thanks:)	09:41
inc0	there will be more work in L	09:41
inc0	about RPC	09:41
inc0	and we'll make bunch of unit tests for this mechanism	09:42
*** rakesh_hs_ has quit IRC		09:42
asalkeld	sounds good	09:42
asalkeld	inc0: maybe make a summit session about it	09:42
*** dims_ has joined #heat		09:43
inc0	there will be one proposed in oslo	09:43
inc0	brb->scrum	09:43
*** aweiteka has joined #heat		09:46
*** alexpilotti has joined #heat		09:47
*** dmn__ has joined #heat		09:51
*** dmn_ has quit IRC		09:51
*** dmn__ has quit IRC		09:53
*** Qiming has quit IRC		09:56
*** pitr-ch has joined #heat		09:59
*** inc0 has quit IRC		10:08
*** Yanyanhu has joined #heat		10:09
*** xek has joined #heat		10:12
*** Yanyan has quit IRC		10:12
*** dmn__ has joined #heat		10:12
*** Yanyan has joined #heat		10:12
*** Yanyanhu has quit IRC		10:14
*** Yanyanhu has joined #heat		10:14
*** aweiteka has quit IRC		10:15
*** inc0 has joined #heat		10:16
*** Yanyan has quit IRC		10:17
*** Yanyan has joined #heat		10:17
*** dmn__ has quit IRC		10:17
*** sergmelikyan has quit IRC		10:19
asalkeld	pas-ha: +A please -> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/116336/	10:19
*** dmn__ has joined #heat		10:20
pas-ha	asalkeld, done :)	10:20
*** Yanyanhu has quit IRC		10:21
*** Yanyan has quit IRC		10:22
asalkeld	thx	10:23
openstackgerrit	Kanagaraj Manickam proposed openstack/heat: Fixes StackWatchService to use objects in place of db https://review.openstack.org/165349	10:29
*** ifarkas has quit IRC		10:44
*** ifarkas has joined #heat		10:47
*** boris-42 has joined #heat		10:51
*** Qiming has joined #heat		10:52
*** jtomasek has joined #heat		10:53
asalkeld	remember meeting in an hour: https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/HeatAgenda	10:55
shardy	asalkeld: question about https://github.com/openstack/heat/blob/master/heat/engine/resources/stack_resource.py#L263	10:56
shardy	if we've stored the failed state, surely the resource record will already be stored?	10:56
shardy	(even if the underlying stack wasn't)	10:57
*** KarolynChambers has quit IRC		10:58
shardy	I'm trying to persist INIT_COMPLETE to the DB for breakpoints, but it turns out the point when you call _store() is important, because _store_or_update doesn't do the same thing (updates different columns)	10:58
*** dulek has quit IRC		11:02
*** dulek has joined #heat		11:02
*** inc0_ has joined #heat		11:02
KanagarajM	asalkeld: as the heat objects are now in place, shall i re-implement https://review.openstack.org/#/c/110557/ ?	11:05
*** inc0 has quit IRC		11:06
*** sorantis has quit IRC		11:07
*** KarolynChambers has joined #heat		11:07
asalkeld	KanagarajM: you could - but it's super low priority	11:10
KanagarajM	asalkeld: ok. sure.	11:11
*** KarolynChambers has quit IRC		11:14
*** rakesh_hs_ has joined #heat		11:15
*** KarolynChambers has joined #heat		11:15
openstackgerrit	Kanagaraj Manickam proposed openstack/heat: Versioned-object StackLock https://review.openstack.org/165363	11:16
*** pitr-ch has quit IRC		11:19
*** KanagarajM is now known as KanagarajM_afk		11:19
*** KarolynChambers has quit IRC		11:21
*** KarolynChambers has joined #heat		11:22
*** sorantis has joined #heat		11:23
*** KanagarajM_afk has quit IRC		11:24
*** KarolynChambers has quit IRC		11:25
*** KarolynChambers has joined #heat		11:26
*** pas-ha has quit IRC		11:27
*** KarolynChambers has quit IRC		11:28
*** cdent has joined #heat		11:29
*** KarolynChambers has joined #heat		11:30
openstackgerrit	Merged openstack/heat: Remove usage of 'long' data type https://review.openstack.org/165277	11:31
*** Drago has joined #heat		11:32
*** Drago has quit IRC		11:33
*** Drago has joined #heat		11:33
*** KarolynChambers has quit IRC		11:35
*** ParsectiX has joined #heat		11:35
*** KarolynChambers has joined #heat		11:36
*** jprovazn has quit IRC		11:37
*** KarolynChambers has quit IRC		11:39
*** jprovazn has joined #heat		11:40
*** pas-ha has joined #heat		11:40
*** KarolynChambers has joined #heat		11:40
*** achanda has joined #heat		11:45
*** KarolynChambers has quit IRC		11:45
asalkeld	akuznetsova: that neutron test seems to have just gotten our tests to the point of timing out	11:45
asalkeld	:-(	11:46
asalkeld	heat_integrationtests.functional.test_autoscaling.AutoScalingSignalTest.test_signal_with_policy_update [832.644550s] ... ok	11:48
akuznetsova	asalkeld, actually, it test take less than 2 min in regular devstack	11:49
*** KarolynChambers has joined #heat		11:49
*** achanda has quit IRC		11:49
*** tspatzier has joined #heat		11:49
asalkeld	akuznetsova: they could just be very slow test machines	11:49
asalkeld	heat_integrationtests.functional.test_instance_group.InstanceGroupUpdatePolicyTest.test_instance_group_update_replace_huge_min_in_service [508.550756s] ... ok	11:49
asalkeld	these tests ^ are normally a lot faster too	11:49
asalkeld	Build timed out (after 125 minutes). Marking the build as failed.	11:50
asalkeld	2 hours - wow	11:50
akuznetsova	the initial and main problem is too slow nodes	11:50
*** sarob has joined #heat		11:50
akuznetsova	need to do something with it	11:50
shardy	asalkeld: I think we may want to rethink that replace_huge_min_in_service test, it kinda worked as a "unit" test, but it's really slow even locally as a functional test	11:51
shardy	I've been running that a lot debugging this init_complete patch	11:51
akuznetsova	we can't skip scenario tests - they are important	11:51
asalkeld	shardy: yeah	11:51
asalkeld	akuznetsova: totally	11:51
shardy	akuznetsova: It didn't say skip anything, we should figure out another way to get coverage of corner cases like that test	11:51
asalkeld	need a bug for this, causes false failures	11:52
*** KarolynChambers has quit IRC		11:54
asalkeld	https://bugs.launchpad.net/heat/+bug/1433555	11:55
openstack	Launchpad bug 1433555 in heat "functional tests are taking too long and cause false failures" [Undecided,New]	11:55
*** sarob has quit IRC		11:55
*** KarolynChambers has joined #heat		11:55
*** KarolynChambers has quit IRC		11:57
asalkeld	ooo, meeting in 2mins	11:58
*** KarolynChambers has joined #heat		11:59
*** david-lyle_afk is now known as david-lyle		12:00
*** KarolynChambers has quit IRC		12:01
skraynev	I have today some corporate event, so will be just partially involved in meeting and work unfortunately	12:01
*** KarolynChambers has joined #heat		12:03
*** KarolynChambers has quit IRC		12:05
*** KarolynChambers has joined #heat		12:06
*** KarolynChambers has quit IRC		12:08
*** KarolynChambers has joined #heat		12:11
*** KanagarajM has joined #heat		12:13
*** dmn__ has quit IRC		12:14
*** rakesh_hs_ has quit IRC		12:15
*** Qiming_ has joined #heat		12:15
*** vijayagurug has quit IRC		12:15
*** Qiming has quit IRC		12:18
*** derekh has joined #heat		12:19
*** KarolynChambers has quit IRC		12:21
*** vishalcdac07 has joined #heat		12:21
*** dims_ has quit IRC		12:22
vishalcdac07	@stevebaker	12:22
*** KarolynChambers has joined #heat		12:22
*** dims_ has joined #heat		12:22
*** sdake has joined #heat		12:23
*** KarolynChambers has quit IRC		12:24
*** aaa__ has joined #heat		12:25
*** KarolynChambers has joined #heat		12:26
skraynev	pas-ha: ping	12:28
pas-ha	skraynev, pong	12:28
skraynev	have you seen my message in slack?	12:28
pas-ha	yep	12:29
*** blues-man has quit IRC		12:29
*** tochi has quit IRC		12:29
skraynev	pas-ha: ok cool. just to want be sure, that you know about it ;)	12:30
*** KarolynChambers has quit IRC		12:31
*** sorantis has quit IRC		12:32
*** tspatzier has quit IRC		12:32
*** KarolynChambers has joined #heat		12:32
*** Qiming has joined #heat		12:33
Qiming	huangtianhua: online?	12:34
*** KarolynChambers has quit IRC		12:35
*** dmn_ has joined #heat		12:35
*** Qiming has quit IRC		12:36
*** KarolynChambers has joined #heat		12:37
*** sdake_ has joined #heat		12:37
*** aaa__ has quit IRC		12:38
*** KarolynChambers has quit IRC		12:39
*** jistr is now known as jistr\|biab		12:39
*** KarolynChambers has joined #heat		12:40
*** sorantis has joined #heat		12:40
*** sdake has quit IRC		12:41
*** KarolynChambers has quit IRC		12:42
*** KarolynChambers has joined #heat		12:43
*** KarolynChambers has quit IRC		12:45
*** KarolynChambers has joined #heat		12:45
*** dulek has quit IRC		12:46
*** blomquisg has joined #heat		12:47
*** KarolynChambers has quit IRC		12:49
*** KarolynChambers has joined #heat		12:50
*** tiantian has joined #heat		12:51
openstackgerrit	Kanagaraj Manickam proposed openstack/heat: Fixes SoftwareConfigService to use Resource object https://review.openstack.org/165342	12:51
*** sarob has joined #heat		12:51
*** KarolynChambers has quit IRC		12:53
openstackgerrit	Angus Salkeld proposed openstack/heat: Set num_engine_workers=2 for gate functional tests https://review.openstack.org/165396	12:53
asalkeld	pas-ha: shardy you think it's ok to have 2 engine workers?	12:54
*** KarolynChambers has joined #heat		12:54
asalkeld	(to speed things up)	12:54
asalkeld	lets see if the tests pass	12:54
pas-ha	yes, exactly	12:54
*** blomquisg has quit IRC		12:54
asalkeld	ok with that i am off to bed	12:55
asalkeld	night all	12:55
*** asalkeld has quit IRC		12:55
*** KarolynChambers has quit IRC		12:55
*** KarolynChambers has joined #heat		12:56
*** sarob has quit IRC		12:56
*** GonZo2K has joined #heat		12:57
*** nkhare has quit IRC		12:58
*** GonZo2K has quit IRC		12:58
*** inc0_ has quit IRC		12:59
*** KarolynChambers has quit IRC		13:00
*** hdd has joined #heat		13:00
*** nkhare has joined #heat		13:02
*** boris-42 has quit IRC		13:02
*** KarolynChambers has joined #heat		13:02
*** hdd has quit IRC		13:04
*** KarolynChambers has quit IRC		13:04
*** radez_g0n3 is now known as radez		13:06
*** KanagarajM has quit IRC		13:07
*** aweiteka has joined #heat		13:08
*** KarolynChambers has joined #heat		13:08
*** rakesh_hs has joined #heat		13:08
*** blomquisg has joined #heat		13:09
*** KarolynChambers has quit IRC		13:11
*** KarolynChambers has joined #heat		13:12
*** KarolynChambers has quit IRC		13:13
*** rakesh_hs has quit IRC		13:14
*** KarolynChambers has joined #heat		13:15
*** rakesh_hs has joined #heat		13:16
*** KarolynChambers has quit IRC		13:19
*** dmn_ has quit IRC		13:19
*** kaufer has joined #heat		13:20
*** KarolynChambers has joined #heat		13:21
*** vijayagurug has joined #heat		13:21
openstackgerrit	Merged openstack/heat: StackResource convert operations to use RPC https://review.openstack.org/116336	13:24
shardy	\o/	13:26
*** KarolynChambers has quit IRC		13:29
*** KarolynChambers has joined #heat		13:31
*** hdd has joined #heat		13:32
*** alexpilotti has quit IRC		13:35
*** KarolynChambers has quit IRC		13:38
*** jistr\|biab is now known as jistr		13:39
*** KarolynChambers has joined #heat		13:39
*** boris-42 has joined #heat		13:41
*** rakesh_hs has quit IRC		13:41
*** KarolynChambers has quit IRC		13:43
*** nzrf has left #heat		13:43
*** jmckind has joined #heat		13:43
*** KarolynChambers has joined #heat		13:43
*** cdent has quit IRC		13:47
*** ishant has quit IRC		13:48
*** dulek has joined #heat		13:49
*** cdent has joined #heat		13:49
*** rakesh_hs has joined #heat		13:50
*** pm90_ has joined #heat		13:52
*** sarob has joined #heat		13:52
*** nkhare has quit IRC		13:53
*** pm90_ has quit IRC		13:53
*** blues-man has joined #heat		13:54
*** pm90_ has joined #heat		13:54
*** rakesh_hs has quit IRC		13:56
*** InblEric has joined #heat		13:57
*** sarob has quit IRC		13:57
*** vishalcdac07 has quit IRC		13:58
*** dulek has quit IRC		13:59
*** sabeen1 has joined #heat		13:59
*** dulek has joined #heat		14:00
*** blues-man has quit IRC		14:00
*** blues-man has joined #heat		14:00
*** aweiteka has quit IRC		14:01
*** alexpilotti has joined #heat		14:03
*** kaufer1 has joined #heat		14:08
*** kaufer has quit IRC		14:09
*** inc0 has joined #heat		14:11
*** kaufer1 has quit IRC		14:13
*** alexpilotti has quit IRC		14:14
*** alexpilotti has joined #heat		14:15
*** kaufer has joined #heat		14:15
*** aweiteka has joined #heat		14:16
*** InblEric1 has joined #heat		14:20
*** InblEric has quit IRC		14:23
*** jmckind has quit IRC		14:27
*** kaufer has quit IRC		14:27
*** kaufer has joined #heat		14:28
*** inc0 has quit IRC		14:28
pas-ha	nope, 2 engine workers did not help - test run timed out	14:29
Qiming_	shardy, there?	14:30
*** jmckind has joined #heat		14:31
Qiming_	anyone has seen this before? heat-api cannot start -> CRITICAL heat-api [-] DuplicateOptError: duplicate option: admin_user	14:32
*** Qiming_ has quit IRC		14:32
*** pitr-ch has joined #heat		14:33
*** Qiming_ has joined #heat		14:33
pas-ha	no, I was wrong, the error is genuinely related to multiple engines http://logs.openstack.org/96/165396/1/check/check-heat-dsvm-functional-mysql/cbd0edd/console.html#_2015-03-18_13_54_23_638	14:33
*** InblEric1 has quit IRC		14:35
*** kebray has joined #heat		14:35
*** lkarm has joined #heat		14:35
*** InblEric has joined #heat		14:35
*** jprovazn has quit IRC		14:38
*** rakesh_hs_ has joined #heat		14:38
*** vijendar has joined #heat		14:40
*** jprovazn has joined #heat		14:41
*** tiantian has quit IRC		14:45
*** achanda has joined #heat		14:47
Drago	Qiming_: randallburt was seeing that yesterday and he probably solved it. He'll be on in a couple of hours. I know I've seen it before but can't remember why it happens	14:48
Qiming_	thanks, Drago	14:49
*** Qiming_ is now known as Qiming		14:49
*** achanda has quit IRC		14:52
*** sarob has joined #heat		14:53
*** InblEric1 has joined #heat		14:55
*** InblEric has quit IRC		14:56
*** sarob has quit IRC		14:58
*** reed has joined #heat		14:59
*** Raj2 has joined #heat		15:04
*** Raj2 has quit IRC		15:04
*** Raj2 has joined #heat		15:05
*** kebray has quit IRC		15:06
*** rakesh_hs_ has quit IRC		15:07
*** rakesh_hs_ has joined #heat		15:07
*** Marga_ has joined #heat		15:07
*** ParsectiX has quit IRC		15:10
*** Trozz has quit IRC		15:10
*** Trozz has joined #heat		15:11
*** InblEric has joined #heat		15:11
*** jaypipes has quit IRC		15:12
*** InblEric1 has quit IRC		15:13
*** hdd has quit IRC		15:14
*** vijayagurug has left #heat		15:21
*** Raj2 has quit IRC		15:24
*** Raj2 has joined #heat		15:24
*** pitr-ch has quit IRC		15:26
shardy	Qiming: I've seen that before, I think I fixed it by removing all my stale oslo stuff (probably oslo.config in this case) and reinstalling oslo.config from pip	15:32
shardy	heat ends up picking up an old installed-from-git version instead of the pip version	15:33
Qiming	shardy, thanks, will give it a try	15:34
*** pitr-ch has joined #heat		15:34
*** Tango has joined #heat		15:37
Qiming	night all	15:37
*** Qiming has quit IRC		15:38
shadower	shardy: okay, the state stuff is indeed quite complicated	15:39
*** kebray has joined #heat		15:39
*** LiJiansheng has quit IRC		15:40
*** packet has joined #heat		15:41
*** dulek has quit IRC		15:44
*** rakesh_hs_ has quit IRC		15:45
*** dulek has joined #heat		15:47
*** Raj2 has quit IRC		15:47
*** Raj2 has joined #heat		15:48
*** spzala has quit IRC		15:49
*** sdake_ has quit IRC		15:51
*** sdake has joined #heat		15:52
*** sarob has joined #heat		15:55
*** hdd has joined #heat		15:55
*** blues-man has left #heat		15:56
*** thedodd has joined #heat		15:59
*** pm90_ has quit IRC		16:00
*** dulek has quit IRC		16:00
*** sarob has quit IRC		16:00
*** InblEric1 has joined #heat		16:06
*** kebray has quit IRC		16:06
*** kebray has joined #heat		16:07
*** InblEric has quit IRC		16:09
*** spzala has joined #heat		16:15
*** jtomasek has quit IRC		16:18
*** sorantis has quit IRC		16:23
*** BManojlovic has quit IRC		16:24
*** KanagarajM has joined #heat		16:25
*** smc7 has joined #heat		16:35
*** Marga_ has quit IRC		16:42
*** Marga_ has joined #heat		16:43
*** Raj2 has quit IRC		16:50
*** Raj1 has joined #heat		16:52
*** KanagarajM has quit IRC		16:53
*** kebray has quit IRC		16:55
*** sarob has joined #heat		16:56
*** pitr-ch has quit IRC		16:58
*** openstackgerrit has quit IRC		16:59
*** openstackgerrit has joined #heat		16:59
*** sarob has quit IRC		17:01
*** pm90_ has joined #heat		17:01
*** alexpilotti has quit IRC		17:02
*** alexpilotti_ has joined #heat		17:02
*** achanda has joined #heat		17:04
*** Raj1 has quit IRC		17:07
*** jistr has quit IRC		17:08
*** InblEric has joined #heat		17:11
*** InblEric1 has quit IRC		17:13
*** randallburt has joined #heat		17:19
*** randallburt has quit IRC		17:21
*** randallburt has joined #heat		17:21
*** harlowja_away is now known as harlowja_		17:27
*** Marga_ has quit IRC		17:28
*** pm90_ has quit IRC		17:29
*** pm90_ has joined #heat		17:29
*** sdake_ has joined #heat		17:31
*** sdake has quit IRC		17:35
*** pitr-ch has joined #heat		17:35
*** InblEric1 has joined #heat		17:36
*** rdo has joined #heat		17:38
*** InblEric has quit IRC		17:39
*** rakesh_hs has joined #heat		17:39
*** coolsvap is now known as coolsvap\|afk		17:41
*** ParsectiX has joined #heat		17:49
*** derekh has quit IRC		17:49
pas-ha	g'night all	17:54
*** pas-ha has quit IRC		17:55
*** sarob has joined #heat		17:57
lkarm	randallburt: drago mentioned that you were seeing this error -- heat-api cannot start -> CRITICAL heat-api [-] DuplicateOptError: duplicate option: admin_user	18:00
lkarm	did you figure out what was happening ?	18:00
randallburt	lkarm: sort of, it was a duplicate config option registered in the authtoken middleware and something else that escapes me atm	18:01
*** sarob has quit IRC		18:02
*** jcoufal has quit IRC		18:02
*** kebray has joined #heat		18:02
*** sdake has joined #heat		18:04
lkarm	randallburt: so you dont remember how to fix it?	18:06
randallburt	lkarm: not really. though you can search for that configuration option and see where its registered.	18:07
*** sdake_ has quit IRC		18:07
*** ParsectiX has quit IRC		18:07
*** ParsectiX has joined #heat		18:08
shardy	lkarm: you probably have a stale version of either python-keystoneclient, keystonemiddleware or both	18:08
shardy	similar errors also happen if you upgrade heat with stale versions of oslo libraries around	18:09
shardy	the solution is to figure out which library the error relates to, completely remove all old versions, then reinstall the required versions via pip	18:09
lkarm	okay thanks, i already tried cleaning up stale olso but not with keystoneclient or keystonemiddleware. let me try that	18:10
randallburt	lkarm: found it again I think, though I doubt its the same. Its registered in the keystone authtoken middleware and also in the keystone v2 auth plugin	18:10
randallburt	lkarm: whoops, ignore my last, that is wrong	18:11
*** Marga_ has joined #heat		18:12
openstackgerrit	Rakesh H S proposed openstack/heat: Convergence prepare traversal https://review.openstack.org/159444	18:15
*** hdd has quit IRC		18:16
*** Raj1 has joined #heat		18:22
*** Raj1 has quit IRC		18:23
*** Raj1 has joined #heat		18:23
*** blomquisg has quit IRC		18:25
*** hdd has joined #heat		18:28
*** kebray has quit IRC		18:29
*** smc7 has quit IRC		18:31
*** hdd has quit IRC		18:33
*** achanda has quit IRC		18:48
*** kebray has joined #heat		18:50
*** Marga_ has quit IRC		18:51
*** Marga_ has joined #heat		18:53
*** jprovazn has quit IRC		18:57
*** sarob has joined #heat		18:58
*** achanda has joined #heat		19:01
*** sarob has quit IRC		19:03
*** alexpilotti_ has quit IRC		19:04
*** Marga_ has quit IRC		19:04
*** Marga_ has joined #heat		19:05
*** liusheng has quit IRC		19:05
*** liusheng has joined #heat		19:06
*** dsneddon is now known as dsneddon_lunch		19:12
*** Tango\|2 has joined #heat		19:13
*** lkarm1 has joined #heat		19:14
*** Tango has quit IRC		19:16
*** lkarm has quit IRC		19:16
*** rakesh_hs has quit IRC		19:21
*** blomquisg has joined #heat		19:23
*** spzala has quit IRC		19:24
*** smc7 has joined #heat		19:28
openstackgerrit	Rakesh H S proposed openstack/heat: Hard delete backup stack after successful update. https://review.openstack.org/128918	19:28
*** dsneddon_lunch is now known as dsneddon		19:29
*** boris-42 has quit IRC		19:37
*** stevebaker has quit IRC		19:39
*** stevebaker has joined #heat		19:40
*** boris-42 has joined #heat		19:42
*** Marga_ has quit IRC		19:43
*** Marga_ has joined #heat		19:44
*** blomquisg has quit IRC		19:51
*** sdake_ has joined #heat		19:52
*** Marga_ has quit IRC		19:54
*** pitr-ch has quit IRC		19:54
*** zigo__ has joined #heat		19:56
*** zigo has quit IRC		19:56
*** sdake has quit IRC		19:56
*** sarob has joined #heat		19:59
*** achanda has quit IRC		20:00
*** jruano has joined #heat		20:01
*** ifarkas has quit IRC		20:01
openstackgerrit	Ton Ngo proposed openstack/heat: Reuse existing template https://review.openstack.org/154620	20:02
openstackgerrit	Ton Ngo proposed openstack/heat: Reuse existing registry https://review.openstack.org/154619	20:02
openstackgerrit	Ton Ngo proposed openstack/heat: Handle parameter overriding in an environment https://review.openstack.org/154618	20:02
*** InblEric has joined #heat		20:03
*** InblEric1 has quit IRC		20:03
*** sarob has quit IRC		20:04
*** kebray has quit IRC		20:11
*** spzala has joined #heat		20:12
*** Raj1 has quit IRC		20:12
*** openstackgerrit has quit IRC		20:14
*** openstackgerrit has joined #heat		20:15
*** kebray has joined #heat		20:18
*** Marga_ has joined #heat		20:21
*** Raj1 has joined #heat		20:22
openstackgerrit	Randall Burt proposed openstack/heat: Ignore migrating environments for deleted stacks https://review.openstack.org/164856	20:31
*** kebray has quit IRC		20:31
*** InblEric has quit IRC		20:33
*** KarolynChambers has quit IRC		20:33
*** Raj2 has joined #heat		20:34
*** KarolynChambers has joined #heat		20:34
*** kebray has joined #heat		20:35
*** InblEric has joined #heat		20:36
*** Raj1 has quit IRC		20:36
*** pm90_ has quit IRC		20:36
*** radez is now known as radez_g0n3		20:38
*** Raj2 has quit IRC		20:39
*** Raj1 has joined #heat		20:39
*** elynn has quit IRC		20:40
*** elynn has joined #heat		20:40
*** pm90_ has joined #heat		20:43
*** InblEric1 has joined #heat		20:44
openstackgerrit	Steve Baker proposed openstack/heat: Func tests use fedora-heat-test-image https://review.openstack.org/163287	20:45
openstackgerrit	Steve Baker proposed openstack/heat: WIP Enable software config integration test https://review.openstack.org/165287	20:45
openstackgerrit	Steve Baker proposed openstack/heat: iniset heat_integrationtests.conf https://review.openstack.org/165286	20:45
*** InblEric has quit IRC		20:47
*** achanda has joined #heat		20:48
*** blomquisg has joined #heat		20:49
*** sdake has joined #heat		20:52
*** ParsectiX has quit IRC		20:52
*** ParsectiX has joined #heat		20:53
*** sdake_ has quit IRC		20:56
*** alexpilotti has joined #heat		20:56
*** sarob has joined #heat		21:00
*** InblEric has joined #heat		21:02
*** InblEric has quit IRC		21:02
*** InblEric1 has quit IRC		21:04
*** hdd has joined #heat		21:05
*** sarob has quit IRC		21:05
*** InblEric has joined #heat		21:11
*** InblEric1 has joined #heat		21:15
*** InblEric has quit IRC		21:18
*** hdd has quit IRC		21:19
*** aweiteka has quit IRC		21:20
*** ParsectiX has quit IRC		21:21
*** ParsectiX has joined #heat		21:21
*** pm90_ has quit IRC		21:22
*** __TheDodd__ has joined #heat		21:27
*** thedodd has quit IRC		21:28
*** jruano has quit IRC		21:30
*** jamielennox is now known as jamielennox\|away		21:31
*** kaufer has quit IRC		21:35
*** ParsectiX has quit IRC		21:38
*** ParsectiX has joined #heat		21:38
*** Marga_ has quit IRC		21:39
*** Marga_ has joined #heat		21:40
*** Marga_ has quit IRC		21:40
*** Marga_ has joined #heat		21:40
openstackgerrit	Steven Hardy proposed openstack/heat: Persist initialized resources to DB on create https://review.openstack.org/164651	21:42
openstackgerrit	Steven Hardy proposed openstack/heat: Remove _store from stack_resource https://review.openstack.org/165622	21:42
openstackgerrit	Steven Hardy proposed openstack/heat: Refactor Resource store logic https://review.openstack.org/165623	21:42
openstackgerrit	Steven Hardy proposed openstack/heat: Resource persist state_reset to DB https://review.openstack.org/165624	21:42
*** Raj1 has quit IRC		21:43
*** randallburt has quit IRC		21:43
*** pm90_ has joined #heat		21:44
*** pm90_ has quit IRC		21:44
*** pm90_ has joined #heat		21:45
shardy	zaneb: If you're still about, I'm giving up for today and I've not made a lot of progress on https://review.openstack.org/#/c/164651/	21:46
*** InblEric1 has quit IRC		21:46
shardy	I've so far failed to find a way to persist resources pre-create without breaking loads of tests in exciting ways and/or breaking functionality	21:46
*** lkarm1 has left #heat		21:46
shardy	If anyone fancies taking a crack at it, feel free :)	21:47
*** InblEric has joined #heat		21:48
zaneb	shardy: so what have you discovered so far?	21:48
shadower	I'm about to hit the sack, will look at it tomorrow	21:48
*** hdd has joined #heat		21:49
zaneb	I can try to maybe make some progress tonight	21:49
*** ParsectiX has quit IRC		21:49
*** spzala has quit IRC		21:50
*** spzala has joined #heat		21:50
*** InblEric1 has joined #heat		21:53
*** GonZo2K has joined #heat		21:55
shardy	zaneb: So, I think the patches I posted there work around the metadata issue, by storing the right thing when we move to CREATE_IN_PROGRESS	21:56
*** InblEric has quit IRC		21:56
zaneb	ok	21:56
zaneb	but the world is still broken?	21:56
shardy	But then I got stuck here:	21:56
shardy	https://github.com/openstack/heat/blob/master/heat/tests/test_volume_utils.py#L74	21:57
*** InblEric1 has quit IRC		21:57
shardy	the resource_id gets set in the Volume persisted in the DB, then the test creates a new volume without loading it from the DB	21:58
shardy	that's one of quite a few test failures	21:58
*** sarob has joined #heat		21:58
zaneb	where does the volume get persisted in that example?	21:59
*** asalkeld has joined #heat		21:59
shardy	zaneb: basically a bunch of stuff is returning name from FnGetRefId, whereas without the store() loop in stack.Stack.store we get the resource ID (which the stubs expect)	22:00
zaneb	ah	22:00
shardy	zaneb: it gets persisted via the stk.store() in tests.utils.parse_stack	22:01
shardy	which, with the loop I added, saves all the resources	22:01
zaneb	hmm, what if we were to persist the resources when we call stk.create()?	22:01
zaneb	(that's what convergence needs anyway)	22:02
shardy	ah, and that's still before we hit the hook, despite us not having moved to CREATE_IN_PROGRESS?	22:02
*** boris-42 has quit IRC		22:02
zaneb	I believe so, yes	22:02
shardy	Cool, yeah maybe that will work better	22:03
zaneb	ok, I can try that out	22:03
shardy	some fresh eyes on this may well yield a simpler approach :)	22:03
zaneb	were most of the problems in the unit tests?	22:03
zaneb	i.e. if I get something passing the unit tests locally is it likely to be good, or are there a bunch more failures in the functional tests awaiting?	22:04
shardy	heat_integrationtests/functional/test_autoscaling.py was failing, but that was initially due to the metadata problem, which should be solved by the reworked _store_or_update	22:04
*** jmckind has quit IRC		22:05
shardy	zaneb: I'd guess getting the unit tests passing will be a good start :)	22:05
zaneb	heh, ok ;)	22:05
shardy	but the test_autoscaling.py may still hold some further excitement	22:05
shardy	in particular I was seeing problems with the InstanceGroup memebers not getting persisted, despite the stack.store persisting all resources	22:06
shardy	Hmm, running test_autoscaling.py on my latest patch series looks OK actually	22:06
shardy	\o/	22:07
shardy	At least my day hasn't been completely wasted ;)	22:07
zaneb	how are you handling storing new resources on stack update?	22:07
*** Raj1 has joined #heat		22:08
shardy	zaneb: Hmm, I'm not handling it explicitly atm, but won't they get stored as soon as they make a state transistion during the update?	22:09
shardy	e.g via state_set?	22:09
zaneb	should do, yeah	22:09
zaneb	I was just curious because it's different behaviour between create vs. update	22:10
shardy	the problem I started out trying to solve was sending a signal to a resource before it goes from INIT_COMPLETE to CREATE_IN_PROGRESS	22:10
shardy	If you set a hook on update, must the resource already exist?	22:10
shardy	or is it valid to set a hook on something which is only getting added via the update?	22:11
zaneb	not necessarily	22:11
*** sabeen1 has quit IRC		22:11
shardy	If so then that's probably missing too, unless we can handle it via persisting the INIT_COMPLETE before we start creating it, like on create	22:11
zaneb	just realised that when I was looking at the error logs yesterday, I was actually looking at the Tempest one instead of the functional test	22:11
zaneb	testtools.matchers._impl.MismatchError: 'state changed' != u'Resource initialized'	22:12
shardy	I've just ben running nosetests -svx heat_integrationtests/functional/test_autoscaling.py to run the test against my devstack heat	22:12
zaneb	hope we don't have to change tempest to get around that :/	22:12
shardy	ugh	22:12
*** jamielennox\|away is now known as jamielennox		22:12
*** Raj1 has quit IRC		22:13
zaneb	in test_show_event	22:13
shardy	well we don't currently expose INIT_COMPLETE as a state at all via the API, so I'm not sure how that breaks tempest	22:13
zaneb	so maybe we just need to suppress creating an event for INIT	22:13
*** crose has quit IRC		22:14
zaneb	possibly your latest patch series already does that	22:14
*** Raj1 has joined #heat		22:14
shardy	No, I deliberately generate one, because bug #1319813 asks for an event	22:14
openstack	bug 1319813 in heat "no event recorded for INIT_* resources" [Medium,In progress] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1319813 - Assigned to Steven Hardy (shardy)	22:14
shardy	we don't have to do that though, for breakpoints/hooks all we need is to make signalling the resource while it's pending create possible	22:15
zaneb	because the reporter didn't know what he was talking about ;)	22:15
shardy	heh	22:15
shardy	Oh wait, actually I did remove it in this version:	22:16
shardy	https://review.openstack.org/#/c/164651/3/heat/engine/resource.py	22:16
* shardy is getting tired		22:16
shardy	I made store() just save the current state, and moved all the state-dependent logic to store_or_update	22:16
shardy	so no event	22:17
zaneb	cool, hopefully that tempest failure will go away then	22:17
shardy	Ok, cool, well I'm going to head to bed, any help much appreciated	22:18
zaneb	cool, thanks for the update	22:18
shardy	feel free to push to my patches, or do something completely different if you have a better idea :)	22:18
shardy	I can pick things up again in the morning as needed	22:19
zaneb	I'll see what I can do before I fall asleep at the keyboard ;)	22:19
*** packet has quit IRC		22:19
shardy	awesome, thanks very much	22:19
*** vijendar has quit IRC		22:20
*** shardy is now known as shardy_z		22:20
*** Drago has quit IRC		22:24
*** Marga_ has quit IRC		22:36
stevebaker	this command is hypnotic when running integration tests locally	22:37
stevebaker	watch heat resource-list -n 5 `heat stack-list -l 1 \| cut -d' ' -f4 \| tail -2 \| head -1`	22:37
stevebaker	\|\| true	22:45
*** Marga_ has joined #heat		22:47
asalkeld	zaneb: is the hook bp really important to tripleO? if so we should mark it higher priority and get a FFE	22:54
asalkeld	atm it is low priority	22:55
stevebaker	defn high priority for tripleo	22:55
asalkeld	ok, set to high	22:57
*** kebray has quit IRC		23:21
*** mburns has quit IRC		23:29
*** Raj1 has quit IRC		23:29
*** dims__ has joined #heat		23:29
*** boris-42 has joined #heat		23:30
*** mburns has joined #heat		23:30
*** dims_ has quit IRC		23:33
*** pm90_ has quit IRC		23:34
*** hdd has quit IRC		23:37
*** smc7 has quit IRC		23:40
*** jrist has quit IRC		23:58

Generated by irclog2html.py 2.14.0 by Marius Gedminas - find it at mg.pov.lt!